ahhh, now we're getting somewhere...so, it's not the end result....Oh, I get that....it's not the end result that has brought me to this point....The end result is what I do use....as a marker...as a measure...but the end all be all is HOW we get there...How is he playing in them....and guess what...he went from playing terribly, andf being one of the primary reasons...to just being a side piece....In almost every game he loses....he turns the ball over...not really surprising...Troy was the worst at turnovers...didn't know what the cowboys had done to one of the most accurate passers I ever saw....nope...it the way he does it....again...what I see...no pressure...targets the WRONG people....and just throws it away.....under pressure he's even worse....
Now....you went all 80's & 90's....which is cool, but the game is different....It's faster and results need to be sooner. So lets go to Carr...probably had a QB coach in 8th grade....throwing camps...7 on 7 leagues all year...and while his completion %%% is kinda low, 59%.....he threw 21 tds....and....wait for it...12 ints....which tells me, HE's NOT the reason they are losing GAMES!
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/C/CarrDe02.htm
Every other HOF QB you mentioned joined HORRIBLE franchises at the time....We...us...the Rams WERE 7-9.....we had to trade up to get this guy...cause, you know...we weren't that bad...not awful.....and again...they weren't in the day of 7 on 7 camps all year....QB coaches...Other than Elway....I don't think any had the natural talent of Carr or Goff...
Yet this guy continues to turn the ball over...in clutch games....he's done this since college.
I never thought about the winning-gene...until I heard Wentz talk about it so much...I'm a winner he said...I've always won....I looked into it....it matters....sometimes. Hell, with QB's it seems to be all the time. And even that can't save you...