Was this really a case of one vs the other? I agree, JJ is a fine player, but - considering our cap limitations - can we overcome his loss with players already on the roster? It appears McVay et al decided yes.
I don't think it gets us very far when people argue Floyd is an average player at arguably a more important position. He isn't and his market reflects that. He is a better player than Fowler, for one. Playing on the same line as AD has helped Floyd. Similarly, playing in the same secondary as Ramsey and Williams helped JJ. After all, this is a team sport, isn't it?
I hope JJ returns for his 3rd contract and plays his best football in a Rams jersey. In a situation similar to many Patriots players, who left, only to return