Your ideas of overpaying are yours as well. Fisher may not value a top WR, if so I don't think that reflects well on him considering his offense and passing game in particular is the main reason we don't make the playoffs.
WR that have panned out. I pasted this from another thread from
@DCH
"Well, Brandon Marshall is a huge part of why the Jets are having such a good year. Maclin's making a nice impact in KC. Steve Smith was massive for Baltimore after he left Carolina. Decker had a good year last season in New York."
I'm not advocating a stupid $50 million a year contract to a receiver. I'm saying a top receiver is more valuable to this team then JJ. And that should effect spending in the off season. Notice I have never once said I don't want him back. I simply don't want him back at $50 million dollars a year.
Watching this offense play the Browns right now I don't see how anyone could not think offense is our absolute #1 off season priority. And yes, JJ is playing well as is the whole defense.