Is anyone impressed by this years "historic" QB class?

[PhillyRam]

I haven't seen a ton of Mensah from Miami, I will watch tonight, but has this class really stood out thus far? Ok State kid has looked good, but not generational or special, and there is talk of him being a top 3 pick.

S8 certainly feeling better & better that we have Simpson in the system, learning for at least a year, maybe two, under Stafford. So far ahead of curve for the inevitable transition to a new QB.

 

[muggmeister]

Mensah came back down to earth last night but that had more to do with Corley being out than anything. I am also glad in the fact that we have Simpson already on board as this years vaunted class of QBs appears to be NOT. I would not want to be picking from this year middling prospects or trade 3 or 4 future 1s for any QB in this class.

 

[PARAM]

Raiola from Oregon looks better than most of them. Not an athletic stud. Not flashy. Just gets the job done, making smart decisions.

 

[dieterbrock]

I said all along that Ty Simpson with a year under his belt with McVay was a better prospect than anyone who might be in the '27 draft

 

[PhillyRam]

I said all along that Ty Simpson with a year under his belt with McVay was a better prospect than anyone who might be in the '27 draft

And if Simpson had stayed in college, he might be QB1 in this upcoming draft.

 

[Coliseum Ram]

I said all along that Ty Simpson with a year under his belt with McVay was a better prospect than anyone who might be in the '27 draft

Same here.

 

[dieterbrock]

And if Simpson had stayed in college, he might be QB1 in this upcoming draft.

And if Ryan Williams would have played like this in '25, Ty wouldnt have been available at pick 13

 

[Ramhusker]

Raiola from Oregon looks better than most of them. Not an athletic stud. Not flashy. Just gets the job done, making smart decisions.

And Stafford’s God-son.

 

[Tano]

I believe the 2028 class is going to be really good.

But then again - once we get there - bleh

 

[Fire Ants]

Just like last year's QB class was supposed to be great, and *poof*... not so much.

 

[PhillyRam]

And if Ryan Williams would have played like this in '25, Ty wouldnt have been available at pick 13

Williams could be a future teammate of Simpson. Returner and big play WR. Probably won't go real high due to last years performance.

 

[kmramsfan]

Raiola from Oregon looks better than most of them. Not an athletic stud. Not flashy. Just gets the job done, making smart decisions.

He 's a big kid at 6-3 / 230, that can make plays with his legs too occasionally.
But other than Fouts, Oregon QB's don't seem to do much at the next level, for some reason

 

[PhillyRam]

Watched Menstemaker (sp?) Tonight. Not impressed. The Simpson pick looks better every week. None of these guys are impressing. The USC QB looks like a project. Manning is all over the place. Looks great one series, looks like crap the next. Mensah has his moments, but not some generational guy. Just a prospect. Haven't watched Carr much so can't comment on him.

So just not wowed by this class, and some of these guys will go back to school.

 

[kurtfaulk]

.

.