Schrodinger's Contested Grab
I don't understand the NFL Draft. I never will. After studying KJ Duff, Antwan Raymond and now Ian Strong, I've watched Rutgers multiple times. I don't understand why their QB, Athan Kaliakmanis wasn't invited to the Combine and became a 7th round pick, yet Kellen Mond was drafted early in the 3rd round in 2021. Why was Garrett Nusssmeier, who at one time was mocked as the top overall selection for the 2026 draft, a compensatory 7th round pick? I don't understand why JJ McCarthy was drafted in the top 10 overall or why Hendon Hooker was taken early in the 3rd round. Why was Brock Purdy nearly an UDFA? Why was Tom Brady a late 6th round pick? In his draft, I honestly was expecting Brady to be an early 1st round selection. I'm not that surprised that Brandon Allen, a journeyman QB3 to PS type player as a former 6th round pick, has had a longer NFL career than Paxton Lynch or Christian Hackenberg, so why were the draft positions of those 3 players so different?
DraftBuzz has Ian Strong deep into the UDFA range. I agree with their grade, I consider Strong to be a marginal NFL prospect. The primary reason for this is the Rams drafted Ben Skowronek in the 7th round of the 2021 draft. I consider Skowronek to be a much better prospect than Strong. Right off the bat, a key factor is Skowronek has superior special teams potential. Indeed, he just made the Pro Browl last season as a special teams player. Skowronek is a much better blocker, more athletic, more versatile and a better route runner than Strong.
If Skowronek is a 7th round prospect, it is difficult to justify giving Strong a draft-worthy grade. If those 2 WRs were competing in training camp and preseason for the very last WR spot on an NFL roster, Strong isn't going to make the team, he's going to get waived.
Let's reframe the question. Both KJ Duff and Duce Robinson are commonly mocked as 1st round draft prospects. Duff and Robinson are both taller and more athletic than Strong. If forced to choose one of the 3, I'm not sure which one I'd draft. I understand why on paper everyone likes Duff and Robinson better. The problem is that in their actual football games, Strong is arguably the most reliable performer of the 3. He and Duff played on the same team, so there is a direct apples-to-apples comparison with the same QB and the same scheme. One reason Strong is productive despite the athletic package not being overly attractive is he's very good at contested catches. Multiple draft experts have suggested that Strong might be the best contested catch WR in the entire country.
Consequently, if you told me that Ian Strong only deserved an UDFA grade, I wouldn't argue with that, I think it is logical and fair. If you then told me that Strong was the UDFA from the 2027 class most likely to become an NFL starting WR, I wouldn't argue with that statement either. Sounds about right to me.
Is Ian Strong a draft sleeper or is he a waste of time? I don't know, I don't understand the draft. Can both answers be simultaneously true?
I don't understand the NFL Draft. I never will. After studying KJ Duff, Antwan Raymond and now Ian Strong, I've watched Rutgers multiple times. I don't understand why their QB, Athan Kaliakmanis wasn't invited to the Combine and became a 7th round pick, yet Kellen Mond was drafted early in the 3rd round in 2021. Why was Garrett Nusssmeier, who at one time was mocked as the top overall selection for the 2026 draft, a compensatory 7th round pick? I don't understand why JJ McCarthy was drafted in the top 10 overall or why Hendon Hooker was taken early in the 3rd round. Why was Brock Purdy nearly an UDFA? Why was Tom Brady a late 6th round pick? In his draft, I honestly was expecting Brady to be an early 1st round selection. I'm not that surprised that Brandon Allen, a journeyman QB3 to PS type player as a former 6th round pick, has had a longer NFL career than Paxton Lynch or Christian Hackenberg, so why were the draft positions of those 3 players so different?
DraftBuzz has Ian Strong deep into the UDFA range. I agree with their grade, I consider Strong to be a marginal NFL prospect. The primary reason for this is the Rams drafted Ben Skowronek in the 7th round of the 2021 draft. I consider Skowronek to be a much better prospect than Strong. Right off the bat, a key factor is Skowronek has superior special teams potential. Indeed, he just made the Pro Browl last season as a special teams player. Skowronek is a much better blocker, more athletic, more versatile and a better route runner than Strong.
If Skowronek is a 7th round prospect, it is difficult to justify giving Strong a draft-worthy grade. If those 2 WRs were competing in training camp and preseason for the very last WR spot on an NFL roster, Strong isn't going to make the team, he's going to get waived.
Let's reframe the question. Both KJ Duff and Duce Robinson are commonly mocked as 1st round draft prospects. Duff and Robinson are both taller and more athletic than Strong. If forced to choose one of the 3, I'm not sure which one I'd draft. I understand why on paper everyone likes Duff and Robinson better. The problem is that in their actual football games, Strong is arguably the most reliable performer of the 3. He and Duff played on the same team, so there is a direct apples-to-apples comparison with the same QB and the same scheme. One reason Strong is productive despite the athletic package not being overly attractive is he's very good at contested catches. Multiple draft experts have suggested that Strong might be the best contested catch WR in the entire country.
Consequently, if you told me that Ian Strong only deserved an UDFA grade, I wouldn't argue with that, I think it is logical and fair. If you then told me that Strong was the UDFA from the 2027 class most likely to become an NFL starting WR, I wouldn't argue with that statement either. Sounds about right to me.
Is Ian Strong a draft sleeper or is he a waste of time? I don't know, I don't understand the draft. Can both answers be simultaneously true?