I think its time to acknowledge the trade off in not playing in the preseason

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
They need to do what many have suggested. Get rid of the preseason COMPLETELY and expand the season to 18 games. It would be really easy.....the extra game would be against a division in the other conference. For instance, the Rams play the AFC West and Buffalo because Buffalo finished 2nd in their division. The 18th game would be against Houston or Baltimore. Really simple.

And though it may sound like whining, I hate the fact you're going to force 2 teams to play a regular season game in a place that takes 15 hours in air time to get there. Ridiculous. Stop trying to ram NFL football down the world's throat. If they want to see NFL football, come to fucking America. That's where it's played. I feel the same way about London or Brazil or Germany or Paris or Mexico. They'll learn when some wacky Mexican cartel kidnaps an NFL head coach or QB. Doesn't it suggest something is wrong when you tell NFL fans "don't wear your teams jersey in Brazil because the gangs down there may mistake you for a rival gang member". Really?
So 3 Extra games if you take away preseason for 20 games, 22 Weeks and Add 3 Div game a Piece. 2 Bye weeks! Qbs can rotate in and out when they want. Most teams carry 3 QBs now anyway. Expand Rosters larger to Maybe 70, with practice squad maybe 20 for the 90!

I get Euro games and all is fine, but all these other areas is stupid.Most dont care about football or just there to experince it once, and move on. Just like most here in the states did with the World Cup.
 
Man! you don't have to play in pre-season to get injured~ Myles Garrett
 
The tenants coach Harbaugh announced he regrets not playing starters in preseason after getting beaten by Cards. Honestly, a series or 2 seems like an acceptable risk to have your team less rusty in the 1st game that matters.

On a potential positive note, our guys never acclimated to a different time zone, so we should have zero negative effects of that in our next game, though I doubt 10 days later ANY team would. I'm looking for positives.
 
Its too much of an oversimplification to look at McVay's record in openers. It ignores the context that I laid out in the original post.

The ONLY team we jumped on was his first ever opener, against the Colts. And that also happens to be the only time we played starters in the preseason.

We played a team every bit as bad as the Colts the following year, and we were losing to them in the third quarter. I won't rehash everything I laid out, but its very important context to my question here.

The overall point is: in almost (2021 is the exception) every first game, we start slow, and the only ones we win are against (often significantly) inferior teams. We've now played three really good teams, and two of them blew our doors off in week one.

The difference between the Niners and us is probably practice habits - but it is worth noting that Purdy did play 12 snaps. That is an entire drive or two where he mentally prepares KNOWING he will play, gets into the huddle on the field, has to worry about the playclock, reads a defense, etc. 12 snaps would probably do the trick for us.

And then the question becomes this:

Is a probably 10% chance (or less) that a starter gets injured worth actually competing against the Niners in week one? Easy answer for me.
 
Well said. I agree, I'd take the risk of a drive or 2 in preseason. Injuries happen in practice even, can't have your team unprepared because you are scared of injuries IMO.
 
2006: 8-8 (Linehan)
2007: 3-13 (Linehan)
2008: 2-14 (Haslett/Linehan)
2009: 1-15 (Spanuolo)
2010: 7-9 (Spagnuolo)
2011: 2-14 (Spagnuolo)
2012: 7-8-1 (Fisher)
2013: 7-9 (Fisher)
2014: 6-10 (Fisher)
2015: 7-9 (Fisher)
2016: 4-12 (Fisher/Fassell)
2017: 11-5 (McVay) Lost WC
2018: 13-3 (McVay) Lost SB
2019: 9-7 (McVay)
2020: 10-6 (McVay) Lost Div
2021: 12-5 (McVay) Won SB
2022: 5-12 (McVay)
2023: 10-7 (McVay) Lost WC
2024: 10-7 (McVay) Lost Div
2025: 12-5 (McVay) Lost Conf

I dunno… looking at the past 20 years, I’ll continue to trust McVay. ;)

(p.s. It was painful to look back to 2006 – 2016. Ten years of pain:explode1:)
 
We lost Sam Bradford for the year in a pre-season game. It isn't worth the injury risk IMO. I like the strategy. More and more teams are adopting it too, so many years, your opponent will be in the same boat. This year was a weird one with Australia. Almost worth writing it off IMO.
Who is this Sam Bradford you speak of? :laugh2: ;)
 
  • HaHa
Reactions: dieterbrock
"Stop trying to ram NFL football down the world's throat. If they want to see NFL football, come to fucking America. That's where it's played."

Exactly! What's the end game here? Have a franchise in Australia? Or even England? Logistically impossible!

Is it for the money (sell out these foreign venues)? The NFL sells out in the US - no need to prove they can sell out on foreign lands.

The whole thing is silly - Goodell always has been - and continues to be - an idiot.
 
"Stop trying to ram NFL football down the world's throat. If they want to see NFL football, come to fucking America. That's where it's played."

Exactly! What's the end game here? Have a franchise in Australia? Or even England? Logistically impossible!

Is it for the money (sell out these foreign venues)? The NFL sells out in the US - no need to prove they can sell out on foreign lands.

The whole thing is silly - Goodell always has been - and continues to be - an idiot.
It's all about the Benjamins or, in this case, TV revenue from areas outside the US. I think -lol.
 
It's all about the Benjamins or, in this case, TV revenue from areas outside the US. I think -lol.
I don't know what the exchange rates are for England and Australia, but the sheer expense of having to haul an entire team across oceans makes the whole thing financially ludicrous.

To me, none of this international shit makes any sense (or dollars :))
 
I don't know what the exchange rates are for England and Australia, but the sheer expense of having to haul an entire team across oceans makes the whole thing financially ludicrous.

To me, none of this international shit makes any sense (or dollars :))
It doesn't make any sense to me either but the owners continue to let Goodell do anything he wants. I guess it's because he is the goose that lays the golden eggs? He has made the owners ridiculous amounts of money during his tenure and that is why he gets paid around 40-60 million per year. It sucks but money talks.
 
Its too much of an oversimplification to look at McVay's record in openers. It ignores the context that I laid out in the original post.
Its not an oversimplification, its a total fact.
The idea that starters playing 2 meaningless drives, in vanilla formations, against vanilla defenses is somehow going to prepare the team is beyond ludicrous.
Playing a quarter of football against an actual opponent is 100X more effective than meaningless plays in August. And guess what? After a little over a quarter the Rams were actually leading the game.
Anyone who's ever played a sport knows that the practices leading up to the game tell the most about how they are gonna play and what happened a month before is irrelevant
 
2006: 8-8 (Linehan)
2007: 3-13 (Linehan)
2008: 2-14 (Haslett/Linehan)
2009: 1-15 (Spanuolo)
2010: 7-9 (Spagnuolo)
2011: 2-14 (Spagnuolo)
2012: 7-8-1 (Fisher)
2013: 7-9 (Fisher)
2014: 6-10 (Fisher)
2015: 7-9 (Fisher)
2016: 4-12 (Fisher/Fassell)
2017: 11-5 (McVay) Lost WC
2018: 13-3 (McVay) Lost SB
2019: 9-7 (McVay)
2020: 10-6 (McVay) Lost Div
2021: 12-5 (McVay) Won SB
2022: 5-12 (McVay)
2023: 10-7 (McVay) Lost WC
2024: 10-7 (McVay) Lost Div
2025: 12-5 (McVay) Lost Conf

I dunno… looking at the past 20 years, I’ll continue to trust McVay. ;)

(p.s. It was painful to look back to 2006 – 2016. Ten years of pain:explode1:)
Furthermore, 2006-2016 they were 3-8 in season openers, and THEY played their starters in pre-season
McVay is 7-3
 
Its not an oversimplification, its a total fact.
The idea that starters playing 2 meaningless drives, in vanilla formations, against vanilla defenses is somehow going to prepare the team is beyond ludicrous.
Playing a quarter of football against an actual opponent is 100X more effective than meaningless plays in August. And guess what? After a little over a quarter the Rams were actually leading the game.
Anyone who's ever played a sport knows that the practices leading up to the game tell the most about how they are gonna play and what happened a month before is irrelevant


You keep saying 7-3....one of those wins (his first), we played starters in the preseason....if you're going to speak on the subject, at least try to be accurate. You should be saying 6-3 for your position.

Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes subscribe to playing in the preseason, so its not nearly as cut and dry as you're making it out to be with your "Anyone who's ever played a sport" bit. I think they've had some success.

Tony Dungy, a former NFL head coach and Super Bowl champion also recently tweeted that he thinks more teams need to play their players in the preseason.

Its also a total fact that 5 of those six wins came against teams that would go on to be bottom feeders that year. But since 2022, we have started the year with teams that would go on to have a winning record each year and guess what our record is since that time in openers?

1-3 (if the Niners end up with a winning record)

How about our record against teams that would go on to make the playoffs?

0-3 (if the Niners make it this year)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tano
You keep saying 7-3....one of those wins (his first), we played starters in the preseason....if you're going to speak on the subject, at least try to be accurate. You should be saying 6-3 for your position.

Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes subscribe to playing in the preseason, so its not nearly as cut and dry as you're making it out to be with your "Anyone who's ever played a sport" bit. I think they've had some success.

Tony Dungy, a former NFL head coach and Super Bowl champion also recently tweeted that he thinks more teams need to play their players in the preseason.

Its also a total fact that 5 of those six wins came against teams that would go on to be bottom feeders that year. But since 2022, we have started the year with teams that would go on to have a winning record each year and guess what our record is since that time in openers?

1-3 (if the Niners end up with a winning record)

How about our record against teams that would go on to make the playoffs?

0-3 (if the Niners make it this year)
I have the same thoughts as you. A couple of series to help get them back into game speed.
 
  • Cheers
Reactions: FrantikRam
"Stop trying to ram NFL football down the world's throat. If they want to see NFL football, come to fucking America. That's where it's played."

Exactly! What's the end game here? Have a franchise in Australia? Or even England? Logistically impossible!

Is it for the money (sell out these foreign venues)? The NFL sells out in the US - no need to prove they can sell out on foreign lands.

The whole thing is silly - Goodell always has been - and continues to be - an idiot.
I'm not sure that its not the owners rather than Goodell that are pushing for off-shore games.
 
I'm not sure that its not the owners rather than Goodell that are pushing for off-shore games.
I's be surprised if that's the case. I'm assuming the NFL pays for the extra expense to send the to wherever. But I'd think the travel definitely adds to the team's expenses and introduces increased risk of losing, when you travel further than normal NFL team home distances.
 
You keep saying 7-3....one of those wins (his first), we played starters in the preseason....if you're going to speak on the subject, at least try to be accurate. You should be saying 6-3 for your position.

Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes subscribe to playing in the preseason, so its not nearly as cut and dry as you're making it out to be with your "Anyone who's ever played a sport" bit. I think they've had some success.

Tony Dungy, a former NFL head coach and Super Bowl champion also recently tweeted that he thinks more teams need to play their players in the preseason.

Its also a total fact that 5 of those six wins came against teams that would go on to be bottom feeders that year. But since 2022, we have started the year with teams that would go on to have a winning record each year and guess what our record is since that time in openers?

1-3 (if the Niners end up with a winning record)

How about our record against teams that would go on to make the playoffs?

0-3 (if the Niners make it this year)
He is 7-3 doing it his way.
Sorry but if you think taking 5-6 snaps in a meaningless August game makes a difference in the second half of an actual nfl game, I don’t know how to even discuss.
It’s so nonsensical
 
  • Like
Reactions: shovelpass