- Joined
- Jun 24, 2010
- Messages
- 35,889
- Name
- Stu

Well I watched it a short time back and replayed most of the throws 2 - 3 times. Aside from the TD pass to Sted (the one that wasn't called back) I came away with the same perception. Originally, I thought the TD pass to Sted hung up like a kite but afterward, saw that it was really a pretty good throw with just a little added loft. I get what you're saying about timing routes and all. I just don't think the timing was as good as you are alluding to and the defender in some cases was able to make up ground from a weak pass.I just rewatched the game. I've got to say, Hill was damn good. Dude was under pressure all game and made some really really good passes. Some were dropped and many great plays were called back.
It also dawned on me why a lot of people MIGHT be thinking he makes a lot of bad passes. He throws a TON of timing routes. If the receiver doesn't make it to the right spot on time, or the defender catches up, it looks like a bad pass. SB and AD don't throw a lot of timing routes so it's not what we're used to seeing.
Good examples are the TD passes to Bailey. The one that got called back that Bailey caught behind the defender's back, Hill released that ball when Bailey was still a yard off the line of scrimmage. Bailey got to where he needed to be and the ball placement and timing were right on. The defender just caught up with him. The second one looks like this arching weak lob but is a timing route. Bailey is just entering the endzone when Hill releases. He HAD to put the lob on it to get it to be in the right spot at the right time. It was perfect.
The second reason is that Hill throws the ball away a lot under pressure by overthrowing the covered receiver. The ball almost always goes high out of bounds or over the covered receivers head to land in the open field. These are smart throws. It's almost always when he's about to be sacked and he's still in the pocket. He avoids the sack and the penalty.
If you re-watch the game with this in mind, is he about to be sacked or this a timing route, his entire game has a different light to it
IMHO, these are the reasons for the Rams success in avoiding the issues AD had. Hill doesn't scramble much. Instead he releases very quickly and throws a timing pass or throws it away. When he does scramble, he's pretty damn good.
We also need to remember that the Chargers are the #7 passing D and earned those interceptions. They were both heads up plays where the defender was stalking the route and came from the opposite side of the receiver.
We'll see how Hill finishes the season, but I agree, I think we have a keeper. I think if people watched with these points in mind, they would change their opinion on Hill.
Anyway, no big deal. He's QBing our team right now so - Go Shaun Hill!!!