50k foot view I think I was just trying to say that their personnel decisions aren't infallible. I have my doubts that Rapp was a top 2 safety on this team at any point last season. Obviously not confirmed and I can't prove it, but it's how I feel.
I think the DB group relies on trust and communication as much as the O line. Passing people off, who the safety helps in different coverage, etc. Scott getting integrated to that was likely to take some time, so sure if they'd started him earlier over Rapp (and made whatever other scheme adjustments necessary) I think there's a good chance he would have delivered that quality of play earlier in the season.
Weddle does muddle the picture significantly. I'll give you that.
In the end I think it's weird that two backup players (Gaines and Scott) stepped in and played as good or better than the starters. Both did better in my opinion, but then again, what the hell do I know? I think sticking by the old "coach Rah is infallible" (obvious hyperbole is obvious and is clearly not intended as an actual view of your position, hopefully) line doesn't give credit to what these players did when we desperately needed them. I've consistently said I disagree with the "MAD plays" philosophy and that's primarily what's keeping Rapp on the field. I don't know about SJD but it might have been the same but to a lesser degree. I don't know.
I think it shows the Rams know what they're doing in developing players.
Gaines is a year behind SJD... Scott is a late round pick who only played DB one season in college.
I look at it as the Rams have kept at it, coaching these guys, and when the opportunity came, they were ready to play. For me it's a lot less about whether they had the "right guy" starting than it is about whether they know what they're doing with the roster, overall. I don't think it's weird that they performed so well, I think it shows the Rams know what they're doing.
You also have to factor in that just because a player's position says "safety", it doesn't mean they're truly interchangeable. Fuller was the deep safety, for the most part, and App stayed closer to the line. Scott came in plenty during the season and, unless I'm forgetting something, primarily played deep. I guess my point with that is that it wasn't about Scott being better or worse than Rapp than it is about them playing different roles.
I'm at the point where it's not blind belief in the team, but I'm less likely to question them now than in the past. They know what they're doing.
I don't have any problem with the MAD stuff, or Rah. I've been one of the most consistently vocal supporters, even when shit didn't look good, because I felt like he was working with a severely limited secondary and he was also learning the defense and the personnel. I feel pretty good about how that played out.
Scott was a revelation in the playoffs... damn was it fun to watch him. But he also got fooled, big time, in the Super Bowl. I have absolutely zero idea if Fuller would've read the play or not and am not saying he would've. I'm more pointing out that Scott still has room to grow. I've loved Scott from the start.... he came into the league with one year of playing DB and was going to work his ass off to make an impact on special teams and keep learning to play DB. He has a joyous attitude that I find very, very easy to root for and I hope he keeps building off his post season.
With Gaines.. one thing that distorts some of his performance is the improbability of some of his plays. Those short legs going full Barney Rubble.. it's a crack up!! That's one of the reason we love it so much.. it feels unexpected.. he's a friggin hoot.. and very, very easy to root for as well. I love the guy. But SJD was the same kind of guy.. great attitude.. a 6th rounder who worked his ass off to get better.. very, very easy to root for and he was damn good. His plays just look different because he's 4 inches taller with longer arms.