Giants hire Patriots assistant coach Joe Judge in surprise move, per report

[Dodgersrf]

Perhaps, but he had the choice of teams and took the Panthers over the Giants. Like Den said, he may prefer Herbert over Jones. Both have a very viable RB and Carolina's better IMO at WR and defense. Plus an owner with very deep pockets who is forking out big money for an analytics department. I think he chose well. Plus no NY media.

All good points.

 

[den-the-coach]

I think he chose well. Plus no NY media.

Plus Carolina breezes & weather far superior.

 

[Angry Ram]

Those guys come out of the Andy Reid and Mike Shanahan coaching trees. Both fairly successful.

The Belichik tree...not so much.

LOL.

BOB, as much of a jerk he is, has had success.

Jim Schwartz took a 0-16 Lions team into a playoff team a couple years later.

Brian Flores is in a shitty situation, but he beat NE...in NE.

Mike Vrabel has gone to the playoffs in back to back years, and just ended the "dynasty".

 

[Elmgrovegnome]

Judge not, lest ye be judged

city

Just heard on the radio that incentive could drive it closer to 90 million.

That's crazy for a college coach

 

[OldSchool]

city




That's crazy for a college coach

It's good to be the next hot young name in coaching. In a few years it'll be Lincoln Riley (at least I think he stays for a couple years).

 

[Merlin]

I wonder how far apart they were.
The NY job is a premier position

Like the others before me here I'm not so sure that is true. The Giants are all over the place nowadays and I'm not sure that Rhule's style matches Gettleman all that well... Gettleman is known for his love of size/power in his roster construction and I don't know that he's going to survive this recent hire btw. Rhule is known for scraping the barrel and developing athletes, changing guys' positions, etc., and it was agreed in Carolina they'd build around him.

NY comes with high taxes (which matters), crime, a$$hole media, pollution, and terrible traffic. Carolinas for me at least are a thousand times better. Only thing I'd love about NY is their pizza, I suspect they put crack in it but that's a whole other discussion.

 

[Selassie I]

Not sure how true it may be... but I heard that Rhule will have much more say and control of everything in Carolina compared to what he would have been given in NY.

 

[Flint]

I heard he was about to get a college gig so they had to do something.
This is starting to look bad for the nfl though, a dope like Kitchens gets a job, a special teams coach outta nowhere gets a job, but a guy like Bienemy who’s paying dues under Andy Reid hears crickets.