Karma, and I enjoyed the ever loving Hell out of it.
If this was about Pete Carroll and the Seahawks would this thread still
ruffle your feathers?
Speaking of Pete Carroll, it's funny how glorified he is as a HC. On another board, somebody made a thread about how overrated Fisher is and I pointed out that Fisher is rated about properly. He's rated as an average to above average HC. Which, of course, then devolved into a conversation of whether Fisher could get a team "over the hump"(pretty stupid debate considering he already did it in 1999).
Anyways, getting to my point, Pete Carroll was a coach thought of in the same light as Fisher. Good team build, would always have you around .500 give or take a couple games...but couldn't get you over the hump. Now, he has Russell Wilson...a franchise QB...and all of a sudden the guy is a brilliant HC and one of the NFL's best.
Same thing was thought of Tony Dungy when he left Tampa Bay. Great defensive mind that couldn't get his team over the hump. Goes to Indy with Peyton Manning and now some people think he's worthy of the HOF.
I guess the point I'm making is that the difference between a guy like Fisher and guys like Carroll and Dungy isn't coaching ability...it's their teams...and really...it's a franchise QB. Fisher hasn't had one since McNair. Maybe it's his fault, maybe not. But if we had/have a franchise QB, nobody will question Fisher's ability to coach.
Now, obviously I avoided mentioning guys like Belichick, Harbaugh, and Coughlin...who are just plain great coaches. Does that mean personnel is irrelevant to those guys? No. But it means that they're capable of elevating a team...I think that's a rare quality for a player or coach.
Some will scoff at Harbaugh and Coughlin but those guys are absolute monsters in the playoffs. Don't know what it is but those guys just have some magic in them that comes out in the playoffs...kind of like Kurt Warner did.