- Joined
- Jan 14, 2013
- Messages
- 29,931
Hmmmm.. I am not in agreement on this. He's on a HOF pace but he's a 285 DT pass rusher and I've seen his type wear down sooner than later when they get close to the 30 year age mark. See John Randall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Randle
I disagree with the John Randle example. He played until he was 36 years old and averaged 11 sacks per year from 30 years old to 34 years old.
I would rather trade him instead of giving him 20 mil per year.
The money used to resign a healthy Sammy Watkins in 2018 as well as plug some holes the Rams have in 2018 is the direction I would choose to go in.
I'd give Donald his extension, sign Watkins, and plug holes. We have the money to do all three. I'm sure as hell not letting a Hall of Fame talent walk.
I could be wrong and he's even better than Randle or Warren Sapp. I still stand firm in my beliefs of how I view the DT position.
Second most important position in football imo.
I respect your opinion but I hope Snead and Demoff take my view on this.. Trade AD sooner than later before singing him to a flat rate of 20 million per year.
No DT will ever deserve the price of a starting QB if I owned an NFL team.
Derek Carr just set the QB market at $25 million per year. $20 million per year is what you're going to pay for an average starting QB.(Hell, Brock Osweiler got $18 million per year) Donald is worse the price of an average starting QB.
I don't care how many pressures the DT gets or how high PFF ranks him overall. A DT just doesn't deserve that kind of cap space imo. Donald has never taken over and won close games since he's been a Ram.
How many close games have we won on the backs of our defense over the past three years? I'm not sure how you could conclude Donald isn't what put us over the edge. He's not a QB, HB, or WR. He's not going to score the game-winning TD. But when we win a 9-3 game, I cannot disagree more with you when you think the best defensive player in the NFL isn't what put us over the top on that day.
If you can assure me he's going to put the Rams on his back and win 2 or 3 more games because he's on the roster.. I will revisit my thoughts on this.
I just don't believe he's anything more special than Warren Sapp or John Randle were in their prime.
I can assure you that Donald is worth at least 2 wins over an average DT on this team if we have a functional offense.
As for Sapp and Randle, they're both all time great DTs and HOFers. Even if Donald is just that special, that's more than special enough for me to back up the Brinks truck.
I've been wrong before jrry so please don't take this post as being a know it all arm chair GM. You are one of the posters on ROD that truly respect
I respect you a lot as well. It's just two guys talking Rams football. We're definitely in the agree to disagree camp here, but that's no big deal.
That's not "he's worth 20MIL a year".
That's the same type of contract his agent doesn't seem to want.
6 years @ 120MIL with 60MIL guaranteed is different than 20MIL a year.
That's $20 million per year in the NFL, though.
And we don't know if that's the contract his agent wants or not. We're not privy to the negotiations.