Three years in a row he's missed games due to injury. His first two years he wasn't a full time starter.
So since we've needed to be able to depend on him, he hasn't been dependable from an injury standpoint. You can say it's silly - but the fact is he's been injured and missed time for 3 years straight now - so your comment about missing TruJo hurts - we knew this was going to happen. He gets injured. Factor that with the reliance on Gaines, who didn't even play last year?
I was behind the personnel decisions in the offseason - but we all knew this was a possibility. We were relying on Quinn/Ogletree/Gaines/Johnson to be significant contributors this year - and that foursome combined to play 26 out of a possible 64 games last year.
And it turns out our depth is even worse this year than it was last year.
And yea I need to stop about the Jenkins thing, but I decided I was only going to be okay with choosing TruJo over him if TruJo didn't get hurt this year. Even if you want to say TruJo is a better player, which itself is debatable, is 75% of a better player really better? No. And now that I've said that again I'll try to tone it down, but it's extremely frustrating.
As for your players in 3 of 4 position groups missing time - I think you've missed my point. We all KNEW that was likely to happen given these players injury histories. A back is not something one easily recovers from in life, much less football. TruJo gets hurt, it's what he does. Gaines hasn't played well coming back from injury. These were all things that easily could have been anticipated.
Hayes getting hurt is not. He has less of an injury history than the others.
The "if healthy" argument is asinine when talking about football - no team is going to stay healthy. You say missing top players from 3 different position groups - but that doesn't paint an accurate picture. If you look at who is left healthy, we should be much better than this. That performance Sunday was the worst I've ever seen given what the offense did.
I get the frustration with TruJo's injury, Frantik. I do.
But he was rolled up on. That could happen to any player on any play in any game. That, alone, doesn't make him injury prone.
All CB's get hurt.
TruJo
Jenkins
Gaines
Joyner
I mean, ALL of them do. Hell, all players get hurt sooner or later if they are NFL starters.
For the record, I'm worried about Quinn's health, too. A lot.
My point about the 3 injuries on the front 4 was not so much the 3 injuries to starters. It was about 3 injuries to starters in a single position group. It was decimating.
Had we lost a DL, a LB, and either a CB or a S, it would not have been as impactful. At least, IMO.
Lastly, I think most of us were quite impressed with Gaines' play until this Lion game. A game where our pass rush all but disappeared.
Good discussion, man.