BonifayRam
Legend
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2013
- Messages
- 13,435
- Name
- Vernon
What's the consensus on barksdale?
Thats there is NO consensus on him here in ROD' land. It ranges from where from the left field where many think he is the best ORT the Rams have had since Jackie Slater days to where I am at on the right that he has a gaping large size hole in his pass protection game & the major surgery to fix it will cost more than he will be worth.
The only consensus I think we can agree on here is .....Currently he is no longer under a Ram contract & able to go play where-ever he desires that will offer him a contract.
.........I also agree with keeping Joe Barksdale. He played poorly in 2014 but he's been solid up until then. ......... Add into that the argument that Barksdale struggles historically against talented 3-4 edge-rushers (hey, who wouldn't) in a season when the quirk of the schedule meant we played against more of those teams than usual (Kansas City for example) and its easy to see why an average right tackle in this league looked a little overmatched at times. What I'd say is that at the moment we need numbers on that o-line. It looks possible, if not probable that Jake Long is done, Scott Wells maybe too. So Greg Robinson is our LT. Saffold LG (I'd personally like to see him at RG where he's a beast of a run blocker) coming off surgery, an untried C in Tim Barnes and a hole at RG. We don't need a hole at RT as well!
Most of all you said RaminExile has good merit to it. Your right that we sure do not need another hole if we let Barksdale sign elsewhere....but I sure would not candy over JB pass blocking issues as you have it was & will continue to result in stalled offensive drives. Signing a deficient pass protector OT to a good size contract just because Fisher has allowed the OL to be in such a bad state is not the way I would go.
I'm going after his replacement with the first selection in this draft if it were me. I going to get a ORT that can be a whole entire package of a NFL right OT. A ORT that does not demand Boudreau having to start our best OL next to him to support & enable Barksdale to line up as a starter.You said that Barksdale had been solid up till this season....I would like to say that up till this season JB had never entered the season as a NFL starter. Going into the 2013 season Barksdale was just a back up. The only body of work JB work in the NFL was nothing more than a 3rd or 4th OT reserve. In 2013 Saffold started the first two games until he was injured that caused him to miss 4 games when Saffold returned they alternated the ORT post between Saffold & JB. That went on until Harvey Dahl was injured the last week of November then Boudreau was forced to turn the ORT post over to JB. So it was not like JB won the starting ORT post over competition but by default being the last man standing.
Once I secure our future ORT, Barksdale & his his expensive contract becomes a heavy weight on this Ram team the next four yrs...thus seriously affecting our ability to sign the 7 or 8 Ram UFA's who enter FA in 2016. fact is there are long term costs to signing Barksdale to this 4 yr contact that he will demand.
Last edited: