MMQB: The NFL's Top Ten Quarterbacks

[Prime Time]

Click link below to listen to the podcast.
***************************************
https://www.si.com/nfl/2017/07/24/nfl-quarterbacks-top-10-tom-brady-aaron-rodgers-matt-ryan

The Top 10 Quarterbacks in Football
By Gary Gramling and Andy Benoit

Number 10—3:41 - Derek Carr(Raiders)

Number 9—10:06 - Eli Manning(Giants)

Number 8—12:00 - Matthew Stafford(Lions)

Number 7—17:06 - Phillip Rivers(Chargers)

Number 6—25:23 - Drew Brees(Saints)

Number 5—31:07 - Andrew Luck(Colts)

Number 4—40:00 - Ben Roethlisberger(Steelers)

Number 3—43:56 - Matt Ryan(Falcons)

(They did #1 before #2)

Number 2—56:27 - Aaron Rodgers(Packers)

Number 1—49:19 - Tom Brady(Patriots)

 

[NERamsFan]

Initial thoughts, Aaron needs to be #1 and Ryan is way too high.

 

[den-the-coach]

Initial thoughts, Aaron needs to be #1 .

 

[Afro Ram]

I think Luck is a little high personally and I would swap Rodgers and Brady. Still solid enough list by order.

 

[Loyal]

Ok, it seems no one is just gonna say it..WTF, where is Sean Mannion?

 

[LesBaker]

I think Luck is a little high personally and I would swap Rodgers and Brady. Still solid enough list by order.

Luck isnt even in the conversation. Let alone that spot.

Did his mother do this list???

 

[Prime Time]

Credit to @LoyalRam

 

[Loyal]

Credit to @LoyalRam

I'm gonna steal this without shame!:rockon:

 

[DCH]

Click link below to listen to the podcast.
***************************************
https://www.si.com/nfl/2017/07/24/nfl-quarterbacks-top-10-tom-brady-aaron-rodgers-matt-ryan

The Top 10 Quarterbacks in Football
By Gary Gramling and Andy Benoit

Number 10—3:41 - Derek Carr(Raiders)

Number 9—10:06 - Eli Manning(Giants)

Number 8—12:00 - Matthew Stafford(Lions)

Number 7—17:06 - Phillip Rivers(Chargers)

Number 6—25:23 - Drew Brees(Saints)

Number 5—31:07 - Andrew Luck(Colts)

Number 4—40:00 - Ben Roethlisberger(Steelers)

Number 3—43:56 - Matt Ryan(Falcons)

(They did #1 before #2)

Number 2—56:27 - Aaron Rodgers(Packers)

Number 1—49:19 - Tom Brady(Patriots)

How the hell is Eli Manning the 9th-best QB in the NFL? 26 TDs to 16 INTs for an 86 passer rating is not top-10 QB material. He had the same season as Jameis Winston, who is like a decade younger and ascending. The fact that he's on the list but Russell Wilson isn't is just silly.

Hell, I'd put Manning behind Wilson, Prescott, Cousins, Palmer... he's duking it out with the Andy Daltons of the world for top-half-of-the-league.

 

[Loyal]

How the hell is Eli Manning the 9th-best QB in the NFL? 26 TDs to 16 INTs for an 86 passer rating is not top-10 QB material. He had the same season as Jameis Winston, who is like a decade younger and ascending. The fact that he's on the list but Russell Wilson isn't is just silly.

.

How the hell is Eli Manning the 9th-best QB in the NFL? 26 TDs to 16 INTs for an 86 passer rating is not top-10 QB material. He had the same season as Jameis Winston, who is like a decade younger and ascending. The fact that he's on the list but Russell Wilson isn't is just silly.

Hell, I'd put Manning behind Wilson, Prescott, Cousins, Palmer... he's duking it out with the Andy Daltons of the world for top-half-of-the-league.

I swear to God I am almost had a heart attack when I thought you said..

Hell, I'd put Mannion behind Wilson, Prescott, Cousins, Palmer... he's duking it out with the Andy Daltons of the world for top-half-of-the-league

lol

 

[Scirca]

My top 10 QB list (realistic):

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Drew Brees
3. Tom Brady
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Matt Ryan
6. Russell Wilson
7. Derek Carr
8. Phillip Rivers
9. Andrew Luck
10. Dak Prescott