Tough but fair article on Rams offensive woes

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

Prime Time

PT
Moderator
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
20,922
Name
Peter
stuart-rams-1.png


Bradford never panned out in St. Louis.
*******************************************************************************
It's strange that he never mentioned the injury bug which plagued Bradford and hindered the Rams O from developing. You would think that would be an important point.
*********************************************************************************
Quarterbacks

Foles posted the lowest QBR in the NFL

Keenum has the lowest QBR in the league

Goff has a lower QBR than Keenum, and has worse statistics than the cellar-dwelling Keenum in nearly every major category (completion percentage, yards per attempt, sack rate, yards per completion, yards per game).

**************************************************************************
Yikes!!! But how can Keenum have the lowest QBR in the league if Goff is even worse?
*****************************************************************************
Offensive line

Los Angeles ranks 31st in yards per carry and has the sixth-worst sack rate, two statistics primarily used to judge offensive lines. The team has the worst drive success rate in the NFL, which speaks to the entire offense’s inability to string together successful offensive plays. Much of the blame for that falls on the offensive line, which has struggled while playing with numerous quarterbacks, running backs and receivers.

Jeff Fisher

The last time one of Jeff Fisher’s teams had a winning record was in 2008. If the Rams lose another game, he will become just the fifth coach in history with five consecutive losing seasons with the same team. The last was David Shula with the Bengals, who was fired midway through his fifth season in 1996.

The one before him was Lou Saban, who resigned midway through his fifth-straight losing season in 1971. A third was Bill McPeak with Washington in the 1960s, who did not see a sixth season, either. The last was Tom Landry, who was the first coach for the expansion Cowboys, in a very different era of pro football.

*********************************************************************************
Thanks for the article FRO. (y)
 

FRO

Legend
Joined
Jun 1, 2013
Messages
5,308
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5
stuart-rams-1.png


Bradford never panned out in St. Louis.
*******************************************************************************
It's strange that he never mentioned the injury bug which plagued Bradford and hindered the Rams O from developing. You would think that would be an important point.
*********************************************************************************
Quarterbacks

Foles posted the lowest QBR in the NFL

Keenum has the lowest QBR in the league

Goff has a lower QBR than Keenum, and has worse statistics than the cellar-dwelling Keenum in nearly every major category (completion percentage, yards per attempt, sack rate, yards per completion, yards per game).

**************************************************************************
Yikes!!! But how can Keenum have the lowest QBR in the league if Goff is even worse?
*****************************************************************************
Offensive line

Los Angeles ranks 31st in yards per carry and has the sixth-worst sack rate, two statistics primarily used to judge offensive lines. The team has the worst drive success rate in the NFL, which speaks to the entire offense’s inability to string together successful offensive plays. Much of the blame for that falls on the offensive line, which has struggled while playing with numerous quarterbacks, running backs and receivers.

Jeff Fisher

The last time one of Jeff Fisher’s teams had a winning record was in 2008. If the Rams lose another game, he will become just the fifth coach in history with five consecutive losing seasons with the same team. The last was David Shula with the Bengals, who was fired midway through his fifth season in 1996.

The one before him was Lou Saban, who resigned midway through his fifth-straight losing season in 1971. A third was Bill McPeak with Washington in the 1960s, who did not see a sixth season, either. The last was Tom Landry, who was the first coach for the expansion Cowboys, in a very different era of pro football.

*********************************************************************************
Thanks for the article FRO. (y)
I don't think Goff qualifies for QBR yet. Bottom line is they need to get better talent around the QB and they need a new direction on offense.
 

FRO

Legend
Joined
Jun 1, 2013
Messages
5,308
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7
I didn't take it aimed at me at all. I agree stats don't lie, but they sure can be misleading. I did however find the draft data enlightening. To me that is the biggest frustration with this regime. A squandered opportunity to build a contending team. Give them good scores for defense and special teams. An F- for offense. Line needs help, but the free agent market is sparse as is the draft, plus not having a first round pick really hurts. I believe the offensive line is holding the entire team back.
 

blackbart

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
6,293
Name
Tim
I wouldn't exactly call it fair since it fails to mention anything abut why some of the players "failed to pan out". For instance no mention of Bailey being shot in the face or the two knee injuries Bradford had.

If you're not going to give all the details how can the analysis be worth the electrons it is written with???
 

Florida_Ram

Hall of Fame
Joined
Jun 18, 2016
Messages
2,622
Here is an article that tries to find solace for extending the HC

Wondering why the Rams gave Jeff Fisher an extension? Here’s one good reason.


By Neil Greenberg December 5
agreed to in the preseason and signed during the season.

The news left everyone in a state of confusion. Before the season began, Fisher hadn’t coached a football team with a winning record since 2008 and led the Rams to records of 7-8-1, 7-9, 6-10, and 7-9 from 2012 to 2015.

This year they are 4-8. According to Louis Bien of SB Nation, no NFL coach since the merger has ever had a losing record through his first four seasons and remained employed by the team.

Fisher is also just two defeats away from setting the record for most career losses by an NFL coach, held by Dan Reeves (165).

imrs.php


“Everybody will want to judge Jeff through the prism of just the record, but that’s totally unfair when you look at the set of circumstances he was handed this year,” Rams Chief Operating Officer Kevin Demoff told NFL Network’s Steve Wyche in November. “It was different than any team in the NFL.

“We moved halfway across the country, then had OTAs in Oxnard. Training camp was in Irvine, now we’re in Thousand Oaks. We moved coaches and players and families. To provide leadership and consistency, he’s done a model job.”

The easy joke is to say Demoff is right: Fisher has been consistent — consistently bad. The common reaction has been to wonder what the heck the Rams are thinking by giving Fisher an extension given his track record.

But perhaps a better question is to ask “how” they’re thinking. And in that context, perhaps Fisher deserves more credit for what he has done for Los Angeles/St. Louis.

Demoff has been quick to point to extenuating circumstances and mitigating factors through Fisher’s tenure. And one of the biggest factors outside of Fisher’s control has been the Rams’ schedule, which has been unusually hard. In 2012, Fisher’s first year with the Rams, he won seven games.

That was five more than the previous year despite playing the second-hardest strength of schedule in the NFL per Football Outsiders’ Defense-adjusted Value Over Average (9.6 percent average DVOA) — which measures a team’s efficiency by comparing success on every single play to a league average based on situation and opponent.

The Arizona Cardinals won five games against the toughest schedule that year, which was only slightly harder (10.8 percent average DVOA) than the one the Rams faced.

In 2013 the Rams again won seven games under Fisher despite having the third-toughest schedule. Their six-win season in 2014 (ninth-toughest), seven wins in 2015 (third-toughest) and five wins this year (fifth-hardest) also don’t seem terrible when looked at in that context.

Only the division rival San Francisco 49ers have played a tougher schedule over the last five seasons combined.

imrs.php


There is a pattern here: the NFC West has been a tough division during Fisher’s tenure. In 2012, the 49ers won 11 games and made it to the Super Bowl. San Francisco made it to the NFC championship game in 2013 only to lose to the divisional rival Seattle Seahawks, who were NFL champions that year.

The Seahawks would make an appearance in the Super Bowl in 2014, too, and last season the Cardinals won 13 games and played in the NFC championship game.

The challenge has been particularly daunting for the Rams offensively. Since 2012, the Rams have faced the first, fourth, fourth, 14th and 10th best collection of defensive talent during the season.

That’s roughly the equivalent of having to play this year’s Minnesota Vikings defense — which ranks sixth in DVOA in 2016, including standing in the top five for yards, first downs and points per drive against — every game for five years straight.

But that doesn’t absolve Fisher completely. The last time a Fisher-led team ranked in the top 15 for offensive yards gained was 2009. The last time his team ranked in the top 15 for points scored was 2008. Both occurred when he was with the Tennessee Titans.

The Rams rank dead last in each category this season and have never been higher than No. 21 under Fisher. Perhaps No. 1 overall pick Jared Goff can help once he gets some experience as an NFL quarterback, but Fisher hasn’t been able to develop a passer into a contributing starter since joining the Rams.

There have been six quarterbacks who have made at least 100 passes in a season for the team under Fisher. The highest Total Quarterback Rating — an opponent adjusted metric that values a quarterback on all play types using a 0-to-100 scale, where higher is better — achieved in a season by one of those quarterbacks was by Sam Bradford, who produced a 58.2 QBR in 2013 over seven games before suffering an injury.

That’s the high point. And before you give Fisher an excuse and say Bradford would have gotten better had it not been for a torn anterior cruciate ligament he suffered in Week 7 that year, consider the game charters at Pro Football Focus had Bradford ranked 21st out of 30 qualified passers through Week 6 of the 2013 season.

The next best performance by a Rams passer under Fisher is Austin Davis, who produced a 50.3 QBR in 2014 over 10 games. To put this in perspective, a QBR of 50 would rank No. 29 out of 31 qualified quarterbacks in 2016. And it just gets worse from there.

imrs.php


Given the lack of production from the game’s most important position, it’s actually surprising the Rams have been as close to average as they’ve been. The reason: Fisher has been a good defensive coach. During his tenure the Rams defense has ranked No. 7, No. 11, No. 9, No. 7 and No. 15 in DVOA from 2012 to 2016.

And their schedule hasn’t done them any favors here, either — this is the first season where their opponents have averaged an offensive DVOA outside of the upper half of the league. And unlike on offense, Fisher has developed some high-end defensive talent.

Defensive tackle Michael Brockers, middle linebacker Alec Ogletree and strong safety T.J. McDonald have all been key contributors, but defensive tackle Aaron Donald has blossomed into one of the best defensive players in the game.

Donald was the 2014 defensive rookie of the year and finished 2015 as a first time All-Pro with 11 sacks. He’s the top-ranked interior defenseman this season per the game charters at Pro Football Focus, demanding that opponents account for him whenever he’s on the field.

One reason the defense looks worse than usual despite facing softer competition is due to poor performance in the red-zone, allowing 71.4 percent of trips inside the 20-yard line to end in a touchdown.

Only the Atlanta Falcons (75 percent) are worse in a league where the average is 56.6 percent. But don’t get out your pitchforks just yet. Bill Barnwell of ESPN found that how a defense performs in the red zone is “almost entirely random,” perhaps giving Fisher another excuse for mediocre performance.

Is Fisher deserving of a coach of the year award? Of course not. And the answer to “what” Fisher has done during his tenure with the Rams — that unpalatable win-loss record — is impossible to overlook. But if you examine the question of “how” he’s done it, you might be able to see why Demoff finds Fisher worthy of an extension.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...heres-one-good-reason/?utm_term=.fc13f2563b42
 

sjm1582002

Wanted everywhere but welcome nowhere
Joined
Jun 18, 2014
Messages
964
The Rams ownership needs to face some uncomfortable facts.

Fisher is either indifferent to, or incapable of, developing a flexible and effective offense plan of attack.

There can be no other reason why, after five years and absent major injuries to key players, a team finds itself at the very bottom of nearly every single offensive measure you care to examine.

What sort of improvement should we anticipate in year six of Fisherball?

A 28th ranked offense seems optimistic with the current staff.
 

OnceARam

Hall of Fame
Joined
Oct 28, 2012
Messages
3,470
Sam Bradford's QBR in 2016 is 55.7, which is less than his QBR under Fisher (58.2).

Clearly that means that Fisher is a better offensive coach that we've given him credit for...
 

kurtfaulk

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Sep 7, 2011
Messages
16,603
Here is an article that tries to find solace for extending the HC

Wondering why the Rams gave Jeff Fisher an extension? Here’s one good reason.


By Neil Greenberg December 5
agreed to in the preseason and signed during the season.

The news left everyone in a state of confusion. Before the season began, Fisher hadn’t coached a football team with a winning record since 2008 and led the Rams to records of 7-8-1, 7-9, 6-10, and 7-9 from 2012 to 2015.

This year they are 4-8. According to Louis Bien of SB Nation, no NFL coach since the merger has ever had a losing record through his first four seasons and remained employed by the team.

Fisher is also just two defeats away from setting the record for most career losses by an NFL coach, held by Dan Reeves (165).

imrs.php


“Everybody will want to judge Jeff through the prism of just the record, but that’s totally unfair when you look at the set of circumstances he was handed this year,” Rams Chief Operating Officer Kevin Demoff told NFL Network’s Steve Wyche in November. “It was different than any team in the NFL.

“We moved halfway across the country, then had OTAs in Oxnard. Training camp was in Irvine, now we’re in Thousand Oaks. We moved coaches and players and families. To provide leadership and consistency, he’s done a model job.”

The easy joke is to say Demoff is right: Fisher has been consistent — consistently bad. The common reaction has been to wonder what the heck the Rams are thinking by giving Fisher an extension given his track record.

But perhaps a better question is to ask “how” they’re thinking. And in that context, perhaps Fisher deserves more credit for what he has done for Los Angeles/St. Louis.

Demoff has been quick to point to extenuating circumstances and mitigating factors through Fisher’s tenure. And one of the biggest factors outside of Fisher’s control has been the Rams’ schedule, which has been unusually hard. In 2012, Fisher’s first year with the Rams, he won seven games.

That was five more than the previous year despite playing the second-hardest strength of schedule in the NFL per Football Outsiders’ Defense-adjusted Value Over Average (9.6 percent average DVOA) — which measures a team’s efficiency by comparing success on every single play to a league average based on situation and opponent.

The Arizona Cardinals won five games against the toughest schedule that year, which was only slightly harder (10.8 percent average DVOA) than the one the Rams faced.

In 2013 the Rams again won seven games under Fisher despite having the third-toughest schedule. Their six-win season in 2014 (ninth-toughest), seven wins in 2015 (third-toughest) and five wins this year (fifth-hardest) also don’t seem terrible when looked at in that context.

Only the division rival San Francisco 49ers have played a tougher schedule over the last five seasons combined.

imrs.php


There is a pattern here: the NFC West has been a tough division during Fisher’s tenure. In 2012, the 49ers won 11 games and made it to the Super Bowl. San Francisco made it to the NFC championship game in 2013 only to lose to the divisional rival Seattle Seahawks, who were NFL champions that year.

The Seahawks would make an appearance in the Super Bowl in 2014, too, and last season the Cardinals won 13 games and played in the NFC championship game.

The challenge has been particularly daunting for the Rams offensively. Since 2012, the Rams have faced the first, fourth, fourth, 14th and 10th best collection of defensive talent during the season.

That’s roughly the equivalent of having to play this year’s Minnesota Vikings defense — which ranks sixth in DVOA in 2016, including standing in the top five for yards, first downs and points per drive against — every game for five years straight.

But that doesn’t absolve Fisher completely. The last time a Fisher-led team ranked in the top 15 for offensive yards gained was 2009. The last time his team ranked in the top 15 for points scored was 2008. Both occurred when he was with the Tennessee Titans.

The Rams rank dead last in each category this season and have never been higher than No. 21 under Fisher. Perhaps No. 1 overall pick Jared Goff can help once he gets some experience as an NFL quarterback, but Fisher hasn’t been able to develop a passer into a contributing starter since joining the Rams.

There have been six quarterbacks who have made at least 100 passes in a season for the team under Fisher. The highest Total Quarterback Rating — an opponent adjusted metric that values a quarterback on all play types using a 0-to-100 scale, where higher is better — achieved in a season by one of those quarterbacks was by Sam Bradford, who produced a 58.2 QBR in 2013 over seven games before suffering an injury.

That’s the high point. And before you give Fisher an excuse and say Bradford would have gotten better had it not been for a torn anterior cruciate ligament he suffered in Week 7 that year, consider the game charters at Pro Football Focus had Bradford ranked 21st out of 30 qualified passers through Week 6 of the 2013 season.

The next best performance by a Rams passer under Fisher is Austin Davis, who produced a 50.3 QBR in 2014 over 10 games. To put this in perspective, a QBR of 50 would rank No. 29 out of 31 qualified quarterbacks in 2016. And it just gets worse from there.

imrs.php


Given the lack of production from the game’s most important position, it’s actually surprising the Rams have been as close to average as they’ve been. The reason: Fisher has been a good defensive coach. During his tenure the Rams defense has ranked No. 7, No. 11, No. 9, No. 7 and No. 15 in DVOA from 2012 to 2016.

And their schedule hasn’t done them any favors here, either — this is the first season where their opponents have averaged an offensive DVOA outside of the upper half of the league. And unlike on offense, Fisher has developed some high-end defensive talent.

Defensive tackle Michael Brockers, middle linebacker Alec Ogletree and strong safety T.J. McDonald have all been key contributors, but defensive tackle Aaron Donald has blossomed into one of the best defensive players in the game.

Donald was the 2014 defensive rookie of the year and finished 2015 as a first time All-Pro with 11 sacks. He’s the top-ranked interior defenseman this season per the game charters at Pro Football Focus, demanding that opponents account for him whenever he’s on the field.

One reason the defense looks worse than usual despite facing softer competition is due to poor performance in the red-zone, allowing 71.4 percent of trips inside the 20-yard line to end in a touchdown.

Only the Atlanta Falcons (75 percent) are worse in a league where the average is 56.6 percent. But don’t get out your pitchforks just yet. Bill Barnwell of ESPN found that how a defense performs in the red zone is “almost entirely random,” perhaps giving Fisher another excuse for mediocre performance.

Is Fisher deserving of a coach of the year award? Of course not. And the answer to “what” Fisher has done during his tenure with the Rams — that unpalatable win-loss record — is impossible to overlook. But if you examine the question of “how” he’s done it, you might be able to see why Demoff finds Fisher worthy of an extension.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...heres-one-good-reason/?utm_term=.fc13f2563b42

Strength of schedule has only been hard because the Rams have to play the seagulls twice and whiners twice when they were both superbowl calibre teams, then the seagulls and cards twice when they were upper echelon nfc teams.

Playing the division hasn't been the problem. Playing unfamiliar teams, whether good or bad, has been the problem. When an article uses strength of schedule as an excuse it doesn't know what it's talking about.

.
 

Mojo Ram

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
23,283
Name
mojo
Playing the division hasn't been the problem. Playing unfamiliar teams, whether good or bad, has been the problem. When an article uses strength of schedule as an excuse it doesn't know what it's talking about.
Yep. The elephant in the room as far as i'm concerned. Fisher's Rams would probably win 10 games/year if the schedule had us playing a SEA/AZ and SF only slate.

Ya'll think 7-9 is bullshit...his out of division record is atrocious. I mean seriously, if you remove the ownage over Tampa Bay and the shitty Browns matchups...Fisher's Rams have only won 5 games in the last three seasons out of division.
FIVE
 

FRO

Legend
Joined
Jun 1, 2013
Messages
5,308
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #16
Yep. The elephant in the room as far as i'm concerned. Fisher's Rams would probably win 10 games/year if the schedule had us playing a SEA/AZ and SF only slate.

Ya'll think 7-9 is bullcrap...his out of division record is atrocious. I mean seriously, if you remove the ownage over Tampa Bay and the crappy Browns matchups...Fisher's Rams have only won 5 games in the last three seasons out of division.
FIVE
Wow. Didn't realize that. I wonder why that is. Did they build the team specifically to compete in the division, or is the coaching/scouting bad whereas they can properly prepare for unfamiliar teams.
 

Florida_Ram

Hall of Fame
Joined
Jun 18, 2016
Messages
2,622
Wow. Didn't realize that. I wonder why that is. Did they build the team specifically to compete in the division, or is the coaching/scouting bad whereas they can properly prepare for unfamiliar teams.

Exactly my issue FRO... and what @mojo said Fisher's Rams have only won 5 games in the last three seasons out of division.
FIVE...


and what @kurtfaulk said When an article uses strength of schedule as an excuse it doesn't know what it's talking about.

There is really no defending the Fish man anymore... Him and his staff have had enough chances no matter what the given excuses or the logic might be.

Hoping Kroenke has seen enough of the facts and has already decided that after the last game ends vs 49ers....

the Fish gets cooked and his Time has finally run out....

addon.php
 

Mojo Ram

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
23,283
Name
mojo
Wow. Didn't realize that. I wonder why that is. Did they build the team specifically to compete in the division, or is the coaching/scouting bad whereas they can properly prepare for unfamiliar teams.
Full breakdown non-divisional wins excluding Tampa and Cleveland under Fisher:
2012
Washington
@ Buffalo

2013
Jacksonville
@ Houston
@ Indianapolis
Chicago
New Orleans
-------------------
2014
Denver
Oakland
@ Washington

2015
Detroit

2016
@ NY Jets
 

FRO

Legend
Joined
Jun 1, 2013
Messages
5,308
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #19
Full breakdown non-divisional wins excluding Tampa and Cleveland under Fisher:
2012
Washington
@ Buffalo

2013
Jacksonville
@ Houston
@ Indianapolis
Chicago
New Orleans
-------------------
2014
Denver
Oakland
@ Washington

2015
Detroit

2016
@ NY Jets
2013/2014 were the peak for Fisher. Had Bradford not got hurt maybe we look at Fisher through a different lense. 2015 and 2016 seem worse than 2012. Seems like the team is regressing.
 

blackbart

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
6,293
Name
Tim
The Rams ownership needs to face some uncomfortable facts.

Fisher is either indifferent to, or incapable of, developing a flexible and effective offense plan of attack.

There can be no other reason why, after five years and absent major injuries to key players, a team finds itself at the very bottom of nearly every single offensive measure you care to examine.

What sort of improvement should we anticipate in year six of Fisherball?

A 28th ranked offense seems optimistic with the current staff.
Or maybe they haven't had the talent and have played the toughest defensive schedule around since Fisher has been with the Rams. Everyone knows the last 3 years have been led by back up QBs why would anyone think those guys were going to lead the Rams anywhere? Goff is the answer, now we'll see if they can get it done with a guy everyone says has the talent needed in the league.