- Joined
- Jul 27, 2010
- Messages
- 30,543
I went back and forth about sharing this story. A next door neighbor/friend in Sacramento was convicted of murder and the circumstances in the court case led him to appeal to the US Supreme Court (Carey vs Musladin).
I believe he was single on the day when I moved to Oregon (same day of the earthquake that shook the Giants vs A's world series). Guy was my friend. He was/is a fiercely loyal friend and we used to hang around and play baseball. His Dad was a minor league baseball player when young and could still hit the crap out of the ball when I pitched to him. In fact, his Dad gave me an Orel Hersheiser rookie card from his collection when the Dodgers beat the A's in 1988 (Guy and his Dad were big A's fans). Guy was into soccer and raced dirt bikes. He had a temper on him, but I was shocked to hear he had been convicted of the murder of his ex-wife's boyfriend, Thomas Strudder.
When I wrote to him in prison, he wrote back that it was all a big mistake. It wasn't murder, he said, it was self defense. It all stemmed from the living situation of his/their son, who he had come to see that day. He said that Strudder was a drug dealer and deals went down in the house with his son in the house. Guy says Strudder came out of the house with a gun, while he argued with his ex-wife. He went back to his car and got his gun out of the glove box and returned with it. He says that Strudder fired first and he fell to the ground and shot his gun. Apparently, it ricohet(ed) and killed Strudder. I don't believe they ever found Strudder's gun, which Guy says the cops were crooked in the case and removed evidence....
Do I believe my friend Guy? Maybe? But I know that if I was a juror in the case and there was no weapon presented as evidence of self defense, I couldn't call it self defense. One of Guy's appeals won in the 9th Circuit in a habeus corpus defense, because the court allowed the family of the victim to wear large buttons with the face of the deceased on it throughout the trial and that it influenced the jury.The original judge said there was nothing wrong with it, the 9th Circuit said differently...and finally the Supreme Court of the United States ruled against him , 9-0 with Justice Kennedy writing the concurrent opinion. It blew my mind to hear Bill OReilly talking about my friend and the case during prime time.
Guy's parents were devastated. His Dad died of a heart attack at a fairly young age. His mother desperately tried to maintain a relationship to Guy's son, when the mother wasn't too keen about the connection. Guy was in Pelican Bay for a while, but I don't know which super-max that he's in now. What an absolute tragedy for all involved.
I've never told that story before to anyone. Do you have a story about a notorious freind? This could be an interesting thread if people contribute, eh counselor? (@jrry32 )
I believe he was single on the day when I moved to Oregon (same day of the earthquake that shook the Giants vs A's world series). Guy was my friend. He was/is a fiercely loyal friend and we used to hang around and play baseball. His Dad was a minor league baseball player when young and could still hit the crap out of the ball when I pitched to him. In fact, his Dad gave me an Orel Hersheiser rookie card from his collection when the Dodgers beat the A's in 1988 (Guy and his Dad were big A's fans). Guy was into soccer and raced dirt bikes. He had a temper on him, but I was shocked to hear he had been convicted of the murder of his ex-wife's boyfriend, Thomas Strudder.
When I wrote to him in prison, he wrote back that it was all a big mistake. It wasn't murder, he said, it was self defense. It all stemmed from the living situation of his/their son, who he had come to see that day. He said that Strudder was a drug dealer and deals went down in the house with his son in the house. Guy says Strudder came out of the house with a gun, while he argued with his ex-wife. He went back to his car and got his gun out of the glove box and returned with it. He says that Strudder fired first and he fell to the ground and shot his gun. Apparently, it ricohet(ed) and killed Strudder. I don't believe they ever found Strudder's gun, which Guy says the cops were crooked in the case and removed evidence....
Do I believe my friend Guy? Maybe? But I know that if I was a juror in the case and there was no weapon presented as evidence of self defense, I couldn't call it self defense. One of Guy's appeals won in the 9th Circuit in a habeus corpus defense, because the court allowed the family of the victim to wear large buttons with the face of the deceased on it throughout the trial and that it influenced the jury.The original judge said there was nothing wrong with it, the 9th Circuit said differently...and finally the Supreme Court of the United States ruled against him , 9-0 with Justice Kennedy writing the concurrent opinion. It blew my mind to hear Bill OReilly talking about my friend and the case during prime time.
Guy's parents were devastated. His Dad died of a heart attack at a fairly young age. His mother desperately tried to maintain a relationship to Guy's son, when the mother wasn't too keen about the connection. Guy was in Pelican Bay for a while, but I don't know which super-max that he's in now. What an absolute tragedy for all involved.
I've never told that story before to anyone. Do you have a story about a notorious freind? This could be an interesting thread if people contribute, eh counselor? (@jrry32 )