I love McVay.
I also question him and occasionally, when warranted, I criticize him as much as any around here...
The Bengals were no juggernaut, but they earned their way just like we did. They were not an easy team to beat, a deceptively good defense, team coached by a McVay disciple...
No run game, no TEs, no OBJ, McVay was missing everything but a QB and a WR. He found a way to win anyways.
I don't think outsiders really understand or appreciate how much McVay is a multi faceted coach... some HCs are Xs and Os guys, play call gurus and uber-coordinator's, some are emotional leaders or effective teachers... McVay does all of those and all at a very high level to boot.. Navigating this team through this season to this ending required every one of McVays skills and instincts and nobody else would've been able to make this happen the way it did.
I respect and understand Jourdans take on this, but I'm of the opinion that McVays SB performance was totally praise worthy.
If OBJ stayed in, if he had Higbee, I bet his run game would've opened up more too and McVays offense would've had a big night against a good defense...
....although if that happened, the narrative would be about how bad Cincinnatis defense was and how any offense could've done that...