Is Warner a first-ballot Hall of Famer?

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

Blue and Gold

Pro Bowler
Joined
Jan 6, 2014
Messages
1,741
Name
B and G
http://www.stltoday.com/sports/foot...cle_561f3c8d-2dff-509f-8b19-25735d4b3e44.html

PHOENIX • There are 25 quarterbacks in the NFL Hall of Fame, but there have been no inductees at the position since Troy Aikman and Warren Moon in 2006.

Dick Vermeil has no doubt the nine-year drought ends Saturday with Kurt Warner.

“I’m confident for sure that Kurt will go in,” said Vermeil, Warner’s coach on the Super Bowl XXXIV championship Rams. “It’s almost impossible to leave him out.”

Given his unusual background and the totally unforeseen start in the NFL, Warner’s accomplishments “will never be done again,” Vermeil said. “What other qualification do you need?”

Well, there were the two NFL MVP honors. The gaudy numbers. Guiding a pair of woebegone franchises to the Super Bowl — the Rams (twice) and the Arizona Cardinals (once).

His playoff numbers deserve special emphasis. Warner is the only player to throw for 300-plus yards in three Super Bowls. Included in that trio of games is a record 414 yards passing in that Super Bowl XXXIV victory over Tennessee to cap the 1999 season.

“His playoff numbers, his quarterback efficiency rating, are better than anybody that’s in the Hall of Fame,” Vermeil said. “And if you took all the quarterbacks that are gonna be Hall of Famers in the future and included his quarterback efficiency rating in playoff games, yards thrown and everything, it’s better than those guys. It’s better than Tom Brady’s, it’s better than anybody’s.”

Mike Martz, Warner’s offensive coordinator in ‘99 and then his head coach, feels the same way about his first-ballot chances.


“How could he not?” Martz said. “He’s a two-time MVP. Took two teams, went to three Super Bowls. Won one. How could he not? And you know, the two that he lost were lost on the final play of the game.”

But there are some voters who wonder about the so-called “hole” in his career, specifically the 2004 season with the New York Giants that bridged the time between his Rams’ tenure (1998-2003) and his Arizona stint (2005-09).

Warner began that Giants season as the starter and played OK, but then was benched in favor of rookie and No. 1 overall draft pick Eli Manning.

“That’s been held against him a little bit from rumors I’ve heard,” Vermeil said. “But if that’s true, then my gosh you’ve got to eliminate everybody. Then neither one of the coaches going into this Super Bowl game can go (to the Hall of Fame) because they’ve been fired before. One of them (Pete Carroll) was fired twice.

“And (wide receiver) Cris Carter, who’s all-everything on television now, was run out of Philadelphia for criminy sakes — for bad reasons. And he’s already in the Hall of Fame.

“So it doesn’t make really good sense. There are no legitimate negatives against Kurt going in.”

Truth be told, a chronic thumb injury from his Arena Football League days contributed as much as anything to Warner’s mid-career lull. It worsened over the years and affected his grip — leading to fumbles — and affected his accuracy.

His career revival in Arizona came after he started to wear a glove on his throwing hand, improving his grip on the football.

“Wearing that glove really helped him,” Martz said.

And whether it’s this year, or sometime in the future, deciding to wear that glove will get him in the Hall of Fame. Because as Marshall Faulk said, leading a Rams offense brimming with playmakers to a pair of Super Bowls was one thing. Doing it again with a less-talented cast in Arizona was another.

“What solidified his Hall of Fame career ... is when he went to Arizona and took that organization to a Super Bowl,” Faulk said.

Even Warner realizes the success in Arizona, coupled with what he accomplished with the Rams, is a key part of his Hall of Fame resume.

“I take great pride in that part of things,” he said. “Just being able to be a part of two organizations — like you said — the losingest team in the ‘90s (the Rams, until early in the ‘99 season).

“And the Cardinals, the losingest team over the last half century. To be a part of taking them to places that they’ve never been before to me is what puts the stamp on my career.

“Whether that has anything to do with the Hall of Fame or anything, that’s who Kurt Warner was. I think that’s the epitome of it. And I’m gonna always look back at that with great pride.”

The fact that the Super Bowl and the Hall of Fame voting is taking place in his adopted hometown of Phoenix has made this an unusual week for the always-busy Warner.

He’s working here this week as an analyst for the NFL Network. But he’s also “working” at home, which means running his kids all over the place. Waking them up in the morning, getting them off to school.

After his Super Bowl Media Day obligations Tuesday, he also coached a son’s flag football team and played spectator at a youth basketball game.

“That’s kind of the coolest part,” Warner said. “If you’re on the road in a hotel, you’re probably thinking about the Hall of Fame even more. People are asking you about it. You’re doing more media stuff.

“Here at home, I get to kind of be normal. I come do my little media stuff for a couple hours, then I go back to being normal.”

But come Saturday morning, Warner says the anxiousness will set in as he awaits the Hall of Fame verdict for 2015.

“You’re gonna start to realize how much more it means to you when you get to those moments,” he said. “But a key for me is I don’t by any means want Saturday to be a negative in any way.

“If I don’t get the call or the knock on the door — however they do it — I don’t want to look at it like, ‘Oh I didn’t make it!’ Or I was defeated in any way. Because this is a tremendous honor to be right in this place.

“And there’s a lot of unbelievable guys that are up for it this year. If I don’t get in, I still want to celebrate the process and celebrate where I’m at, and maybe more importantly, celebrate those five that go in.”
 

kurtfaulk

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Sep 7, 2011
Messages
16,608
.

how is that even a question?

and peter king, aka doughboy, can shove his "hole" up his arse. you just know he was thinking about chomping down a few donuts when he was talking about the hole in kurt's career.

i wonder how he will view tom brady's entire shady career? who am i kidding, he will slurp him up like the syrup from his plate after downing 20 pancakes.

.
 

GabesHorn

GRACE AND TRUTH
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
1,125
Its gotta be a close vote with so many players getting backlogged since the NFL only has so few go in each year and they have now opened up so many catagories for consideration as contributors and past players that should have gotten in long ago and have simply been overlooked compared to the players of today.

The league has changed so much pre and post Superbowl era and many rule changes that truly changed the game. So glad less concussions are just now starting to occur if its even believable or just NFL hype again. I truly believe Junior Seau will HAVE to be one of the only 3 players able to be 1st Ballot Hall Of Famers with his duration of play and at such a high level and with a condition no one was ever aware of. GOD rest his soul.

Kurt Warner and Orlando Pace are the only other two 1st Ballot finalists in the final 18 names besides Seau who was eligible this year for the first time. As much as Kurt Warner is at the mountain top for me I would think Seau is more of a lock in just the five PLAYERS that will go in this year. We have coaches and contributors and I think a vet on the list that can make it.

The NFL seems to be adding a wide reciever every year now to try and break the longtime logjam at the position going foreward getting Chris Carter in last year and probably the WR from the Bills finally gets in this year in Lofton. The backup in that lineup must keep moving so Ike Bruce and maybe Torry Holt one day can join the ranks and our Auburn LB that wore 91 for us old guys in Kevin Greene has been a finalist so many time I truly feel for him and his yearly rollercoaster he is doomed to ride.

Just too many great players that played and are as deserving as many that have preceded them. some players that have won SB's and never been a finalist like Jim Plunkett just amaze me how we can justify the system. Everything has to be going your way as you need 80% of the voters approval for entry and such a small group of people vote.Some of whom I personally think others should have the right over some who have the HONOR of voting someone IN or OUT of the earthly Immortals of the NFL world.

I personally hope Kurt Warner can be the next RAM inducted out of so many greats he is up with.I fell in love with the Los Angeles Rams in my childhood as my 3 brothers all were home state Dolphin fans as we had seen the phins practice at Byscane College in Miami early 60's where we were all 4 born before moving to the Panhandle of Florida where we all spent most of our growing up years in Panama City and its wonderfull beaches the kids now abuse at Spring Break.(I digress).I was one out of 4 that chose to root for a team totally across the nation that had these awesome White horns with a QB named Gabriel and many other "Hollywood Heroes" like Deacon,Merlin,Isaiah that had a young Christian to believe from The City of Angels this had to be GOD'S team.LOL Forgive me for the religion mention.

Then when Kurt Warner was to be interviewed after just winning his 1st SuperBowl and game MVP for his still record 414 yards passing and Kurt owns second and third place also in Superbowl passing yards in his 3 games played. Kurt was asked by I believe Mike Tirico interviewing him saying"First things First" Kurt interrupted and said "First Things First" "Thankyou JESUS". Even Kurts boyhood idol Roger Staubach never said such things on this grandest of stages. Now First Things First is the name of Kurts biggest charities as he has also won "Man of the Year" award(The Walter Payton award") for all he does for others in building homes to coat drives still being held to this day each year in St. Louis. Kurt never forgot St. Louis and has even commented against the Rams moving back to L.A.

Now Kurt as he was being interviewed after winning the NFC Championship game in Phoenix by Terry Bradshaw who's brother is a pastor and expected Kurt to make another such reference had Kurt state his famous line abouting people believing in him and the Cardinals shocking the world against the Steelers and by one awesome ballet catch over 3 defenders in the back of the end zone that reminded me of the almost block of the pass by Ram defenders by an inch to Stallworth in the 4th quarter of SB XIV by our two great DB's Pat Thomas and Nolan Cromwell who just missed tipping that game winning pass away.

We will know soon enough as the announcement is now made on an NFL awards show (NFL HONORS) compared to a phone call that probably still comes sometime before.Goodluck Kurt,Orlando and Kevin Greene all once wearers of the Famous HORNS whether White,Yellow or Gold.Hey even our young drafted Battering RAM Jerome Bettis is a finalist also as a L.A. Ram. Soon was nicknamed "The Bus" in Pitts burgh. I'm sure I'm missing other RAM connections for this years finalists. GO RAMS!
 

Blue and Gold

Pro Bowler
Joined
Jan 6, 2014
Messages
1,741
Name
B and G
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #4
.

how is that even a question?

and peter king, aka doughboy, can shove his "hole" up his arse. you just know he was thinking about chomping down a few donuts when he was talking about the hole in kurt's career.

i wonder how he will view tom brady's entire shady career? who am i kidding, he will slurp him up like the syrup from his plate after downing 20 pancakes.

.

Yeah, it's not a question in my mind . . . but there have been questions in a couple voters minds it seems
 

CGI_Ram

Hamburger Connoisseur
Moderator
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
49,232
Name
Burger man
His story is HOF worthy, if strikes go against his longevity.
 

Dieter the Brock

Fourth responder
Joined
May 18, 2014
Messages
8,196
If "thank you Jesus" is a problem I don't care at all if he's elected
Wearing #13 and defiding all stereotypes and superstition taught me all I need to know
Jesus Christ is my savior and Lord and fuck all those who think professing one's faith should predicate otherwise
Okay so if Jesus isn't cool, and if you're all geared up otherwise for than all you need to do is bow to the Pharaoh
 
Last edited:

LesBaker

Mr. Savant
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
17,460
Name
Les
If "thank you Jesus" is a problem I don't care at all if he's elected
Wearing #13 and defiding all stereotypes and superstition taught me all I need to know
Jesus Christ is my savior and Lord and freak all those who think professing one's faith should predicate otherwise
Okay so if Jesus isn't cool, and if you're all geared up otherwise for than all you need to do is bow to the Pharaoh

Huh? What?
 

jrry32

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
29,941
Yes. There's no doubt in my mind.
 

TSFH Fan

Epic Music Guy
Joined
Dec 5, 2014
Messages
1,483
Yes. My memory could be shot to heck, but I remember the pre-Warner Rams and Cards as being not just bad teams, but historically bad franchises -- Rams were on the verge of losingest team of the 90s or something. They were franchises where careers went to die. It could be that Warner was just a right place/right guy, fortuitous confluence of circumstances, etc., but I don't remember anyone ever "rise above" the mess and take two different franchises to the heights that he did.
 

Corbin

THIS IS MY BOOOOOMSTICK!!
Rams On Demand Sponsor
2023 Sportsbook Champion
Joined
Nov 9, 2014
Messages
12,180
Yes. My memory could be shot to heck, but I remember the pre-Warner Rams and Cards as being not just bad teams, but historically bad franchises -- Rams were on the verge of losingest team of the 90s or something. They were franchises where careers went to die. It could be that Warner was just a right place/right guy, fortuitous confluence of circumstances, etc., but I don't remember anyone ever "rise above" the mess and take two different franchises to the heights that he did.
I watched or heard a interview I believe it was the 1999 season that we were paying the Bengals and the loser would be the most losingest franchise in the 90's. We won that game! :)
 

drasconis

Starter
Joined
Jul 31, 2014
Messages
810
Name
JA
Not only did he take two bad frachises to the SB it could be argued that the franchises were clearly not the same after he left. The Rams played pretty good with Bulger (but the post season wasn't good without him). IN the cards case, man did they crash again fast! I remember an the season after he left he and another announcer were doing an interview for a network with one of the cards players (someone on defense) and they asked what the difference was that year for the cards cause they were clearly not going to make the post season, the guy siad he didn't want to say, but they prodded him...he just bashfully pointed at Kurt.

I remember the game where he was playing for the cards and we knocked him out part way through. The O had been buzzing, moving the ball on us...it wasn't looking pretty. In comes Leinert, suddenly their O was bad, same players but they couldn't move the ball much less threaten to score. That is the difference he made in that team.
 

LesBaker

Mr. Savant
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
17,460
Name
Les
Not only did he take two bad frachises to the SB it could be argued that the franchises were clearly not the same after he left. The Rams played pretty good with Bulger (but the post season wasn't good without him). IN the cards case, man did they crash again fast! I remember an the season after he left he and another announcer were doing an interview for a network with one of the cards players (someone on defense) and they asked what the difference was that year for the cards cause they were clearly not going to make the post season, the guy siad he didn't want to say, but they prodded him...he just bashfully pointed at Kurt.

I remember the game where he was playing for the cards and we knocked him out part way through. The O had been buzzing, moving the ball on us...it wasn't looking pretty. In comes Leinert, suddenly their O was bad, same players but they couldn't move the ball much less threaten to score. That is the difference he made in that team.

One of the things he did in AZ was help change the culture too. If you recall the elder Bidwill was slowly turning the franchise over to his son at the same time Warner arrived and within a couple of years the son was appointed President. That was the point where that clubs fortunes changed, and Warner according to everyone in the know, was a big part of the attitude adjustment.

In other words he helped them break the circle of suckitude.
 

DaveFan'51

Old-Timer
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Apr 18, 2014
Messages
18,666
Name
Dave
Yes. My memory could be shot to heck, but I remember the pre-Warner Rams and Cards as being not just bad teams, but historically bad franchises -- Rams were on the verge of losingest team of the 90s or something. They were franchises where careers went to die. It could be that Warner was just a right place/right guy, fortuitous confluence of circumstances, etc., but I don't remember anyone ever "rise above" the mess and take two different franchises to the heights that he did.
Maybe, Peyton Manning, But his two teams weren't that Bad!
 

blue4

Hall of Fame
Joined
Jun 25, 2014
Messages
3,126
Name
blue4
If "thank you Jesus" is a problem I don't care at all if he's elected
Wearing #13 and defiding all stereotypes and superstition taught me all I need to know
Jesus Christ is my savior and Lord and freak all those who think professing one's faith should predicate otherwise
Okay so if Jesus isn't cool, and if you're all geared up otherwise for than all you need to do is bow to the Pharaoh

Maybe something got deleted before I got here but I didn't see anyone saying anything against Jesus.