Creating the All-Time Rams Roster: Offensive Line

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

Best Tackle All-Time?

  • Orlando Pace

    Votes: 9 60.0%
  • Jackie Slater

    Votes: 6 40.0%

  • Total voters
    15

JKBOGEN

JAKE OLIVER ELLENBOGEN
Joined
Jun 26, 2016
Messages
1,747
Creating the All-Time Rams Roster: Offensive Line
gettyimages-228214.jpg

http://theramswire.usatoday.com/2016/06/28/creating-the-all-time-rams-roster-offensive-line/

By: Jake Ellenbogen | 15 hours ago

In this new series, we will break down our All-Time Rams roster position-by-position. We last covered the tight ends, and now it’s time to move on to the offensive line. We’ll have five starters and five backups for this position.

Starting offensive tackle: Jackie Slater
gettyimages-280106.jpg


Arguably the greatest offensive lineman in Rams history, Jackie Slater out of Jackson State plowed lanes for Hall of Fame running back Eric Dickerson. Slater is a Hall of Famer in his own right, and is also a seven-time Pro Bowler.

Slater was the definition of a Rams legend. He started 211 games over his franchise record 20 years with the team — a record that will likely never be broken.

He’s the obvious choice to start, because while players have been great for the Rams, Slater is arguably one of the greatest offensive lineman ever.

Starting offensive tackle: Orlando Pace
gettyimages-657604.jpg


Alas, the cornerstone of the Greatest Show on Turf. Orlando Pace was a once in a generation type prospect out of Ohio State University. How insane was Pace? Well, for starters, he finished top five in the Heisman Trophy voting as a lineman and he basically invented the idea of a pancake block.

The 2016 NFL Hall of Fame inductee was a force for the Rams, starting 154 games for the franchise. Despite his success, Pace had a tendency to look at other teams. He held out multiple times, but came back to the team each time.

Pace would start at right tackle with Slater plugged in on the left side. He is absolutely a lock to make this team on anyone’s list.

Starting offensive guard: Tom Mack
gettyimages-51617143.jpg


One of the greatest offensive guards of all time out of Michigan State. Mack was the second pick in the 1966 NFL draft by the Rams. He was the definition of a winner, and a very productive bull in the trenches.

He started 162 games over the course of his time in Los Angeles, which totaled all 13 seasons of his career. Mack had all the accolades, including 11 Pro-Bowl appearances, four All-Pro first team selections and four All-Pro second team selections. Mack was also named the number seven overall offensive guard of all time by Bleacher Report.

It’s pretty obvious where and why Mack fits on this All-Time roster.

Starting offensive guard: Dennis Harrah
gettyimages-89750889.jpg


The former Miami Hurricane was drafted No. 11 overall in the 1975 draft, and he carved out a decorated career with the Los Angeles Rams. Just like Mack, he played 13 seasons with the Rams, which was the length of his entire career.

Harrah started 144 games, was a first-team All-Pro and a six-time Pro-Bowler. He was a part of six NFC West titles, but never won the big one. The franchise great could be considered a Hall of Fame snub also, as he was highly productive and is an obvious choice to make this roster.

Starting center: Doug Smith
gettyimages-89751236.jpg


It was tough, but the former Bowling Green alumni gets the nod over his predecessor Rich Saul. Doug Smith paid his dues, he waited in the wings while Saul’s time came to an end.

Smith was underrated, but he showed once he got his shot that it didn’t matter. He started 160 games and went to the Pro Bowl six times. Smith gets the slight nudge over Saul.

Backup OT: Charley Cowan
The fifteen-year tenured Ram came from New Mexico Highlands via the 1961 NFL draft. He was taken in the fourth round and just like the previous names, he played his entire career with the team.

Obviously Cowan makes the team, but while he was pretty stellar, going to three Pro-Bowls and playing 206 games, he wasn’t on the freakish level Slater and Pace were.

Backup OT: Bob Brown
The man dubbed The Boomer, Bob Brown only played two seasons with the Rams, but guess what? He was a first-team All-Pro and Pro-Bowler in each of those two seasons. Unfortunately, the Rams traded him to the Raiders.

Due to the lack of seasons with the Rams, the Hall of Famer is just going to earn the nod as a backup this time around.

Backup OG: Tom Newberry
gettyimages-2718857.jpg


Tom Newberry is still a favorite of Rams fans today. He played all but one season with the Rams, and is a two-time All-Pro and two-time Pro-Bowler. He started 128 games out of the 131 total he played.

If his competition weren’t two crazy talents, he might have cracked the starting lineup.

Backup OG: Kent Hill
gettyimages-71499154.jpg


First off, look at that mammoth of a man in the picture above. That right there is Kent Hill, and he is a former five-time Pro-Bowler with the Rams. He started 95 games before being traded to the Houston Oilers for the eventual all-time passer in Rams history, Jim Everett.

Backup C: Rich Saul
The late, great Rich Saul started 106 games in horns and went to six Pro-Bowls in the process. It seems wrong that he’s a backup here, but that is because Smith had about 44 more games started than Saul.

Honorable Mention
Riley Matheson, OG
The five-time Pro-Bowl guard from Texas El-Paso played eight of his 10 seasons with the Cleveland and Los Angeles Rams. He was also playing in a time period when players played multiple positions, unlike today’s standards. Matheson had 12 interceptions, while playing both offense and defense.

Adam Timmerman, OG
Another former Greatest Show on Turf team member won two Super Bowls, one of which came with the Rams. Timmerman also had two Pro-Bowl appearances and a selection to the All-Pro second team. The man from South Dakota State started 124 of his 126 total games for the Rams.

Joe Scibelli, OT
The former Fighting Irish alumni was drafted by the Rams in the 10th round of the 1961 NFL draft. He would go on to be named to a Pro-Bowl and start 132 games for the Rams over a span of his full 15-year career.
 

Roman Snow

H.I.M.
Joined
Dec 22, 2015
Messages
2,615
Name
John
This is pretty solid. We can nibble around the edges of starter/backup, but I think the author hits all the right guys. ...ok maybe Irv Pankey should be there instead of (edit Brown). (n)
 
Last edited:

DaveFan'51

Old-Timer
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Apr 18, 2014
Messages
18,666
Name
Dave
Creating the All-Time Rams Roster: Offensive Line
gettyimages-228214.jpg

http://theramswire.usatoday.com/2016/06/28/creating-the-all-time-rams-roster-offensive-line/

By: Jake Ellenbogen | 15 hours ago

In this new series, we will break down our All-Time Rams roster position-by-position. We last covered the tight ends, and now it’s time to move on to the offensive line. We’ll have five starters and five backups for this position.

Starting offensive tackle: Jackie Slater
gettyimages-280106.jpg


Arguably the greatest offensive lineman in Rams history, Jackie Slater out of Jackson State plowed lanes for Hall of Fame running back Eric Dickerson. Slater is a Hall of Famer in his own right, and is also a seven-time Pro Bowler.

Slater was the definition of a Rams legend. He started 211 games over his franchise record 20 years with the team — a record that will likely never be broken.

He’s the obvious choice to start, because while players have been great for the Rams, Slater is arguably one of the greatest offensive lineman ever.

Starting offensive tackle: Orlando Pace
gettyimages-657604.jpg


Alas, the cornerstone of the Greatest Show on Turf. Orlando Pace was a once in a generation type prospect out of Ohio State University. How insane was Pace? Well, for starters, he finished top five in the Heisman Trophy voting as a lineman and he basically invented the idea of a pancake block.

The 2016 NFL Hall of Fame inductee was a force for the Rams, starting 154 games for the franchise. Despite his success, Pace had a tendency to look at other teams. He held out multiple times, but came back to the team each time.

Pace would start at right tackle with Slater plugged in on the left side. He is absolutely a lock to make this team on anyone’s list.

Starting offensive guard: Tom Mack
gettyimages-51617143.jpg


One of the greatest offensive guards of all time out of Michigan State. Mack was the second pick in the 1966 NFL draft by the Rams. He was the definition of a winner, and a very productive bull in the trenches.

He started 162 games over the course of his time in Los Angeles, which totaled all 13 seasons of his career. Mack had all the accolades, including 11 Pro-Bowl appearances, four All-Pro first team selections and four All-Pro second team selections. Mack was also named the number seven overall offensive guard of all time by Bleacher Report.

It’s pretty obvious where and why Mack fits on this All-Time roster.

Starting offensive guard: Dennis Harrah
gettyimages-89750889.jpg


The former Miami Hurricane was drafted No. 11 overall in the 1975 draft, and he carved out a decorated career with the Los Angeles Rams. Just like Mack, he played 13 seasons with the Rams, which was the length of his entire career.

Harrah started 144 games, was a first-team All-Pro and a six-time Pro-Bowler. He was a part of six NFC West titles, but never won the big one. The franchise great could be considered a Hall of Fame snub also, as he was highly productive and is an obvious choice to make this roster.

Starting center: Doug Smith
gettyimages-89751236.jpg


It was tough, but the former Bowling Green alumni gets the nod over his predecessor Rich Saul. Doug Smith paid his dues, he waited in the wings while Saul’s time came to an end.

Smith was underrated, but he showed once he got his shot that it didn’t matter. He started 160 games and went to the Pro Bowl six times. Smith gets the slight nudge over Saul.

Backup OT: Charley Cowan
The fifteen-year tenured Ram came from New Mexico Highlands via the 1961 NFL draft. He was taken in the fourth round and just like the previous names, he played his entire career with the team.

Obviously Cowan makes the team, but while he was pretty stellar, going to three Pro-Bowls and playing 206 games, he wasn’t on the freakish level Slater and Pace were.

Backup OT: Bob Brown
The man dubbed The Boomer, Bob Brown only played two seasons with the Rams, but guess what? He was a first-team All-Pro and Pro-Bowler in each of those two seasons. Unfortunately, the Rams traded him to the Raiders.

Due to the lack of seasons with the Rams, the Hall of Famer is just going to earn the nod as a backup this time around.

Backup OG: Tom Newberry
gettyimages-2718857.jpg


Tom Newberry is still a favorite of Rams fans today. He played all but one season with the Rams, and is a two-time All-Pro and two-time Pro-Bowler. He started 128 games out of the 131 total he played.

If his competition weren’t two crazy talents, he might have cracked the starting lineup.

Backup OG: Kent Hill
gettyimages-71499154.jpg


First off, look at that mammoth of a man in the picture above. That right there is Kent Hill, and he is a former five-time Pro-Bowler with the Rams. He started 95 games before being traded to the Houston Oilers for the eventual all-time passer in Rams history, Jim Everett.

Backup C: Rich Saul
The late, great Rich Saul started 106 games in horns and went to six Pro-Bowls in the process. It seems wrong that he’s a backup here, but that is because Smith had about 44 more games started than Saul.

Honorable Mention
Riley Matheson, OG
The five-time Pro-Bowl guard from Texas El-Paso played eight of his 10 seasons with the Cleveland and Los Angeles Rams. He was also playing in a time period when players played multiple positions, unlike today’s standards. Matheson had 12 interceptions, while playing both offense and defense.

Adam Timmerman, OG
Another former Greatest Show on Turf team member won two Super Bowls, one of which came with the Rams. Timmerman also had two Pro-Bowl appearances and a selection to the All-Pro second team. The man from South Dakota State started 124 of his 126 total games for the Rams.

Joe Scibelli, OT
The former Fighting Irish alumni was drafted by the Rams in the 10th round of the 1961 NFL draft. He would go on to be named to a Pro-Bowl and start 132 games for the Rams over a span of his full 15-year career.
I have to disagree on your choice for Center, To me Saul and Smith where Great But, to me they are #2 and #3 behind Iman!!
The rest of your picks are fine, no real quarrel! BUT OLT Irv Pankey deserves at least a Back-Up role on any All Time List!! Just-My-Humble-Old-Opinion!!:mrburnsevil:
 

JKBOGEN

JAKE OLIVER ELLENBOGEN
Joined
Jun 26, 2016
Messages
1,747
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #4
This is pretty solid. We can nibble around the edges of starter/backup, but I think the author hits all the right guys. ...ok maybe Irv Pankey should be there instead of (edit Brown). (n)
Thank you!
 

OldSchool

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
40,569
One thing I'll correct is Slater will start at Righ Tackle. He played there the majority of his whole career. Pace would be the Left Tackle.
 

Ramhusker

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
14,462
Name
Bo Bowen
Hard to argue much with the list given here. Good job!
 

Ramhusker

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
14,462
Name
Bo Bowen
I voted Pace but damn, Slater was the man.