The ultimate QB - Agree or disagree?

[Prime Time]

That pic is current QB's only and I mostly agree with it but my list would include all QB's throughout NFL history:

Heart - Kurt Warner
Head - Joe Montana
Arm strength - Jeff George
Arm accuracy - Dan Marino
Body - Brett Favre(the Iron Man)
Legs - Steve Young

 

[-X-]

Head, release, accuracy - Dan Marino
Arm strength, Legs - John Elway

 

[bwdenverram]

Might as well give that QB his arm as well. That way he'd be an ambidextrous QB! #unstoppabledoubleguns

Paul- Not sure how you did it but love the new Avatar. Very cool man.

 

[Memento]

I can't disagree with it for current quarterbacks, but I'll go a little further:

Head: Peyton Manning.
Arm Strength: Aaron Rodgers.
Arm Accuracy: Andrew Luck.
Body Type: Cam Newton.
Legs: Russell Wilson.
Heart: Drew Brees.

 

[12intheBox]

Ryan Fitzpatrick's mustache.

 

[den-the-coach]

I'll go Old School to a degree

Heart - Jim Kelly
Head - Roger Staubach
Arm strength - John Elway
Arm Accuracy - Johnny Unitas
Body - Dan Fouts
Legs - Fran Tarkenton

 

[Selassie I]

Extra mic in the helmet with limp balls... That would be brady!

 

[Dr C. Hill]

My QB doesn't need "legs".
I will take Marino with Cutler's arm.

 

[den-the-coach]

Ram Quarterbacks

Heart - Kurt Warner
Head - Pat Haden (Gulp)
Arm strength - Vince Ferragamo
Arm Accuracy - Norm Vanbroklin
Body - Roman Gabriel
Legs - James Harris

 

[12intheBox]

Ram Quarterbacks

Heart - Kurt Warner
Head - Pat Haden (Gulp)
Arm strength - Vince Ferragamo
Arm Accuracy - Norm Vanbroklin
Body - Roman Gabriel
Legs - James Harris

I'll just take Kurt across the board.

Except for the thumb, of course! Give me the thumb of ..... Marc Bulger.

 

[den-the-coach]

I'll just take Kurt across the board.

Except for the thumb, of course! Give me the thumb of ..... Marc Bulger.

Really was not trying to list a QB twice and I can't disagree with the exception of size & arm strength..Gabriel & Ferragamo get the edge over the only Field General to lead the Rams to a Super Bowl triumph.

 

[Robocop]

hahaha. just the dumbest thing I've ever seen. jesus the NFL Network is really running out of things to talk about right now.

 

[Memphis Ram]

For this list one could put Kurt Warner for legs. I don't think I've ever seen a slower looking qb when we scrambled lol

Former Cardinals QB Jim Hart made Kurt Warner look like a sprinter.

 

[Elmgrovegnome]

Cam Newton's body

Is this something you think about often?

 

[Elmgrovegnome]

I refuse to include Brady in any part of the optimum QB talk-head, legs, arm or whatever. Why? Because we really dont know if Brady is as good as Brady. How much has cheating enhanced his performances?

 

[Legatron4]

Knees- Sam Bradford

 

[RAGRam]

Knees- Sam Bradford

You bastard you beat me to the obvious Bradford's knees/legs/shoulder/ankle/body joke

 

[Zaphod]

Head: Warner
Arms: Bruce, Holt, Proehl, Hakim
Body: Pace, Nutten, Grutadauria, Timmerman, Miller
Legs: Faulk

Sorry, couldn't resist.

 

[jjab360]

Body: Cam Newton

Also, don't really think you need the half Brady head. I get that NFL Network wants to give him a shout out, but it's really not that close who has a better understanding of the game between the two.

 

[snackdaddy]

If I had to pick a quarterback who's closest to all those traits I'd go with Rogers. He can run pretty good when he has to. Got a good arm. Pretty smart too.

 

[blue4]

I'd go with Dan Marino's physical tools and Warner's intangibles.
Warren "Mr Underrated" Moon's longevity and Neil Lomax's name on the jersey because Neil Lomax is a cool ass name.

In my perfect offense a QB doesn't require legs except to drop back and pass on or stand on in the huddle.