Red Star / Black Dot

[12intheBox]

Was listening to a movethesticks podcast and DJ was talking about a practice that they had in the Ravens war room. Each scout was allowed to give one player in their scouting area (no one actually grades 300+ players in real life) a red star if they really wanted a guy or a black dot if they really didn't want him on the team.

So let's play scout. In this draft - who do you give a red star to and who gets a black dot?

(You only have one of each)

 

[Athos]

Being more realistic:

Cooper gets the red star.

Gregory gets the black dot.

 

[Mackeyser]

Cooper the Red Star

Shane Ray the Black Dot...

 

[Corbin]

Cooper Red Star

Black Dot Jameis Winston

 

[ChrisW]

Cooper - Red Star
DGB - Black Dot

 

[12intheBox]

Wow - Cooper with 4 red stars out of the gate!

 

[Merlin]

It's hard to argue with Cooper getting the red star. Still, I'll go with Scherff due to the way his addition settles down the Rams' need on the OL for the remainder of the draft.

Black star is tough because there are a few that I really, really don't like. Gotta go with Gregory I suppose because of his talent vs sureness of being a bust.

 

[CGI_Ram]

Being more realistic:

Cooper gets the red star.

Gregory gets the black dot.

That would be mine.

 

[Memento]

Leonard Williams gets the red star.

Randy Gregory gets the black dot.

 

[DaveFan'51]

Cooper - Red Star
DGB - Black Dot

I couldn't do better than this^!!

 

[PressureD41]

Todd Gurley red star

Randy Gregory big as$ black dot