BCS presidents approve four-team major college playoff

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

-X-

Medium-sized Lebowski
Joined
Jun 20, 2010
Messages
35,576
Name
The Dude
http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/ ... 55845112/1

WASHINGTON – The long, slow march toward a major college football playoff is over. It has been approved.

Conference commissioners met with an oversight committee of university presidents and chancellors in Washington Tuesday to approve the four-team seeded playoff, consisting of two semifinal games in bowls and a national championship game that will be put up for bid.

Commissioners presented the plan for 30 minutes then took questions from the presidents, who then deliberated for about three hours before announcing their approval.

"A four-team playoff doesn't go to far," said Virginia Tech president Charles Steger, chair of the presidential oversight committee. "It goes just the right amount."

The 14-year reign of the Bowl Championship Series— and the persistent criticism that accompanied it - is finally near its send. The near deal will go for 12 years.

"This was timely, had to be done," former Big 12 acting commissioner Chuck Neinas said before Tuesday's meetings began. "(It was in) response to the public, response to the interest in college football. The BCS has done a great deal in helping promote college football, and there's a general feeling we need to do something better to determine a national champion."

The presidents also endorsed the concept of the semifinals rotating among six bowls.

"We do not know the rotation yet," said BCS executive director Bill Hancock. "That's still to be determined."

And they endorsed the idea of a selection committee for the playoff teams, which would end the combination of computer and human polls that have been lightening rods for criticism since the BCS began.

Current BCS contracts run through the 2013 season, so the playoff would go into effect after the 2014 season.

"I'm glad to see it, quite frankly," said former Georgia coach and athletic director Vince Dooley at the national athletic directors convention in Dallas. "It's something that needs to be done. The BCS has had, I think, too much controversy. You can always have some controversy, but this was a lot of controversy - Auburn being a classic example (finishing unbeaten and shut out of the national championship game in 2004). I think this will help to solve a lot of it, and also be productive economically to a lot of schools."
 

Username

Has a Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
5,763
It's a step in the right direction, but I still don't get only four teams. People say it will effect the regular season. I don't really get how so. If the kids are in the playoffs they won't give a shit trust me.

You can say it's a greater risk of injury to the draft pussies, or you can say you're getting NATIONAL ATTENTION for 3-4 nights.

Put in more bye weeks, or do something. Figure it out.

What would it had been last year?

Alabama
LSU
Oklahoma State
Oregon

?

Would've been a fucking crush fest by Bama anyway. Seeing Stanford Alabama would've been fun though. :idk:
 

Angry Ram

Captain RAmerica Original Rammer
Joined
Jul 1, 2010
Messages
17,860
Ehh I really didn't mind the old system. I got a kick of hearing fans/radio guys whining and bitching over various things like schedules and "deserve to play."

Like LSU for example, they played teams like Northwestern State, Miss. State, Kentucky, Auburn, Tennessee, Western Kentucky (huh?), Ole Miss. Really?

Bradford's 2nd year (my 2nd year there too :bign: ), OU played so many cupcake teams: Baylor, Chattanoga (what?!), Washington, Kansas St, Kansas, Nebraska, etc. I knew they were more fluff. Not saying they were a bad team, but ppl kept saying "where's your school spirit" whenever I pointed that out.

College football just needs to be about teams and the experience, instead its constant bitching over "what ifs."
 

Ramhusker

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
13,785
Name
Bo Bowen
Angry Ram said:
Ehh I really didn't mind the old system. I got a kick of hearing fans/radio guys whining and bitching over various things like schedules and "deserve to play."

Like LSU for example, they played teams like Northwestern State, Miss. State, Kentucky, Auburn, Tennessee, Western Kentucky (huh?), Ole Miss. Really?

Bradford's 2nd year (my 2nd year there too :bign: ), OU played so many cupcake teams: Baylor, Chattanoga (what?!), Washington, Kansas St, Kansas, Nebraska, etc. I knew they were more fluff. Not saying they were a bad team, but ppl kept saying "where's your school spirit" whenever I pointed that out.

College football just needs to be about teams and the experience, instead its constant bitching over "what ifs."

I got your cupcake hanging! I ought to take your Captain America shield for putting Nebraska on that list of teams.

But this four team playoff deal is a good compromise for the time being. I guess the NCAA has to go socialist a bit and create some kind of revenue sharing for smaller schools so a Chattanooga doesn't have to schedule an Oklahoma for the extra dough. Then, the regular season could be one game and this playoff could expand to 8 teams.
 

Angry Ram

Captain RAmerica Original Rammer
Joined
Jul 1, 2010
Messages
17,860
Ramhusker said:
Angry Ram said:
Ehh I really didn't mind the old system. I got a kick of hearing fans/radio guys whining and bitching over various things like schedules and "deserve to play."

Like LSU for example, they played teams like Northwestern State, Miss. State, Kentucky, Auburn, Tennessee, Western Kentucky (huh?), Ole Miss. Really?

Bradford's 2nd year (my 2nd year there too :bign: ), OU played so many cupcake teams: Baylor, Chattanoga (what?!), Washington, Kansas St, Kansas, Nebraska, etc. I knew they were more fluff. Not saying they were a bad team, but ppl kept saying "where's your school spirit" whenever I pointed that out.

College football just needs to be about teams and the experience, instead its constant bitching over "what ifs."

I got your cupcake hanging! I ought to take your Captain America shield for putting Nebraska on that list of teams.

But this four team playoff deal is a good compromise for the time being. I guess the NCAA has to go socialist a bit and create some kind of revenue sharing for smaller schools so a Chattanooga doesn't have to schedule an Oklahoma for the extra dough. Then, the regular season could be one game and this playoff could expand to 8 teams.

OK OK as a Capn I'm humble and admit my mistake, Nebraska had a good year that season. Except against OU...which is why it was a cupcake...for them.

IDK, I just feel there's gonna be a helluva more bitchin w/ this system. "Why does X team deserve the 4th spot when Y team went undefeated?!?!?" RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE!!!!!
 

Ramhusker

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
13,785
Name
Bo Bowen
Angry Ram said:
Ramhusker said:
Angry Ram said:
Ehh I really didn't mind the old system. I got a kick of hearing fans/radio guys whining and bitching over various things like schedules and "deserve to play."

Like LSU for example, they played teams like Northwestern State, Miss. State, Kentucky, Auburn, Tennessee, Western Kentucky (huh?), Ole Miss. Really?

Bradford's 2nd year (my 2nd year there too :bign: ), OU played so many cupcake teams: Baylor, Chattanoga (what?!), Washington, Kansas St, Kansas, Nebraska, etc. I knew they were more fluff. Not saying they were a bad team, but ppl kept saying "where's your school spirit" whenever I pointed that out.

College football just needs to be about teams and the experience, instead its constant bitching over "what ifs."

I got your cupcake hanging! I ought to take your Captain America shield for putting Nebraska on that list of teams.

But this four team playoff deal is a good compromise for the time being. I guess the NCAA has to go socialist a bit and create some kind of revenue sharing for smaller schools so a Chattanooga doesn't have to schedule an Oklahoma for the extra dough. Then, the regular season could be one game and this playoff could expand to 8 teams.

OK OK as a Capn I'm humble and admit my mistake, Nebraska had a good year that season. Except against OU...which is why it was a cupcake...for them.

IDK, I just feel there's gonna be a helluva more bitchin w/ this system. "Why does X team deserve the 4th spot when Y team went undefeated?!?!?" RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE!!!!!

I think you never get rid of the bitchin. I mean look at NCAA Basketball. You put 68 teams in the tournament and you still hear it from fans of another 6 teams why their team should be in. Obviously, college football can't have such a tournament but this 4 team action is a step in the right direction. I mean come on, DI FB is the only college sport without some sort of playoffs. The bowl system never has quite answered the question of who the best team is. Even a "mini" playoff will come closer to getting that answer.
 

JdashSTL

Pro Bowler
Joined
Jun 24, 2010
Messages
1,178
Ramhusker said:
I think you never get rid of the bitchin. I mean look at NCAA Basketball. You put 68 teams in the tournament and you still hear it from fans of another 6 teams why their team should be in. Obviously, college football can't have such a tournament but this 4 team action is a step in the right direction. I mean come on, DI FB is the only college sport without some sort of playoffs. The bowl system never has quite answered the question of who the best team is. Even a "mini" playoff will come closer to getting that answer.

Agreed. Most of the high profile bowl games were still awesome, but we're just left with these "what if" scenarios once its all over. I dont think the 4 team playoff will be permanent though, I think it could go to 8, 16 may be too much.
 

brokeu91

The super shrink
Joined
Jul 10, 2010
Messages
5,546
Name
Michael
Ramhusker said:
Angry Ram said:
Ehh I really didn't mind the old system. I got a kick of hearing fans/radio guys whining and bitching over various things like schedules and "deserve to play."

Like LSU for example, they played teams like Northwestern State, Miss. State, Kentucky, Auburn, Tennessee, Western Kentucky (huh?), Ole Miss. Really?

Bradford's 2nd year (my 2nd year there too :bign: ), OU played so many cupcake teams: Baylor, Chattanoga (what?!), Washington, Kansas St, Kansas, Nebraska, etc. I knew they were more fluff. Not saying they were a bad team, but ppl kept saying "where's your school spirit" whenever I pointed that out.

College football just needs to be about teams and the experience, instead its constant bitching over "what ifs."

I got your cupcake hanging! I ought to take your Captain America shield for putting Nebraska on that list of teams.

But this four team playoff deal is a good compromise for the time being. I guess the NCAA has to go socialist a bit and create some kind of revenue sharing for smaller schools so a Chattanooga doesn't have to schedule an Oklahoma for the extra dough. Then, the regular season could be one game and this playoff could expand to 8 teams.
I totally agree that the playoffs should be expanded to 8 teams. One team might go undefeated until the last week and then drop out of the top 4 and not make the playoffs, while another team with one loss or even two may make it over them. If you expand to 8, then the #9 team really doesn't have that much that can say about not making the championship game. I think 8 is fair, 4 could be problematic.
 

Angry Ram

Captain RAmerica Original Rammer
Joined
Jul 1, 2010
Messages
17,860
Ramhusker said:
Angry Ram said:
Ramhusker said:
Angry Ram said:
Ehh I really didn't mind the old system. I got a kick of hearing fans/radio guys whining and bitching over various things like schedules and "deserve to play."

Like LSU for example, they played teams like Northwestern State, Miss. State, Kentucky, Auburn, Tennessee, Western Kentucky (huh?), Ole Miss. Really?

Bradford's 2nd year (my 2nd year there too :bign: ), OU played so many cupcake teams: Baylor, Chattanoga (what?!), Washington, Kansas St, Kansas, Nebraska, etc. I knew they were more fluff. Not saying they were a bad team, but ppl kept saying "where's your school spirit" whenever I pointed that out.

College football just needs to be about teams and the experience, instead its constant bitching over "what ifs."

I got your cupcake hanging! I ought to take your Captain America shield for putting Nebraska on that list of teams.

But this four team playoff deal is a good compromise for the time being. I guess the NCAA has to go socialist a bit and create some kind of revenue sharing for smaller schools so a Chattanooga doesn't have to schedule an Oklahoma for the extra dough. Then, the regular season could be one game and this playoff could expand to 8 teams.

OK OK as a Capn I'm humble and admit my mistake, Nebraska had a good year that season. Except against OU...which is why it was a cupcake...for them.

IDK, I just feel there's gonna be a helluva more bitchin w/ this system. "Why does X team deserve the 4th spot when Y team went undefeated?!?!?" RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE!!!!!

I think you never get rid of the bitchin. I mean look at NCAA Basketball. You put 68 teams in the tournament and you still hear it from fans of another 6 teams why their team should be in. Obviously, college football can't have such a tournament but this 4 team action is a step in the right direction. I mean come on, DI FB is the only college sport without some sort of playoffs. The bowl system never has quite answered the question of who the best team is. Even a "mini" playoff will come closer to getting that answer.

There's gonna be a LOT more than compared to basketball. There's bound to be SEC favoritism complainers and whatnot. Football playoffs work in the NFL b/c it is all 1 league, here there's just too many.

And again, I just wish ppl would just forget about all the bowl nonsense and just worry about the game and experience. OK State won the Fiesta Bowl and their fans were damn happy, just as much as Alabama fans were.